Menu

New York City

The 16 Best Milkshake Spots in New York

When it comes to finding the perfect milkshake in New York, the options can seem overwhelming. With so many milkshake spots to choose from, how can a milkshake enthusiast decide where to go for the best creamy, sweet treat? That's where this page comes in to help you narrow down your choices and find the ultimate milkshake in New York.

Whether you're craving a classic vanilla milkshake, a decadent chocolate milkshake, or a unique flavor combination, New York City has something for every milkshake lover. From trendy shops to classic diners, you're sure to find a milkshake spot that satisfies your sweet tooth craving. So, sit back, relax, and let this guide lead you to the best milkshake in the city that never sleeps.

Now, without further ado, here is a curated list of The 16 Best Milkshake Spots in New York for you to explore and find your new favorite milkshake destination in the Big Apple.

How this guide is ordered

Chosen by our New York editors from places across the five boroughs, giving weight to a long track record with locals, current opening details and how well each one delivers on what it promises. Lists are revisited often; tell us when a spot closes or moves.

Featured businesses may pay for a more visible position within the guide.

Top 3Full listMapHow to choose

Quick view

Featured options

Select an option to see its summary.

#1
Shake Shack Herald Square
4.510,235 reviews
#2
Shake Shack Theater District
4.413,698 reviews
#3
Shake Shack Madison Square Park
4.56,731 reviews

Full list

Compare 16 local options

Shake Shack Herald Square#1
What stands out

  • The quick service even during busy times

  • The enjoyable and satisfying taste of the dishes

  • The friendly and hardworking staff that provides excellent service

  • The value for money and variety of choices on the menu

Shake Shack Herald Square

4.510,235 reviews
1333 Broadway, New York, NY 10018, United States

Shake Shack Herald Square is a renowned Hamburger restaurant located in New York, offering a variety of services and features for its customers. The establishment provides Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in options, ensuring convenience and flexibility for patrons. With its fast service and delectable menu items, Shake Shack is popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining, catering to a diverse range of preferences.

Customer reviews highlight the positive experiences at Shake Shack, with key points including:

One satisfied customer mentioned, "The burger I had there was juicy, flavorful, and cooked to perfection. The cheese fries are also a must-have try! It’s so worth it." Another patron praised the staff for their friendliness and the reasonable prices, recommending the YUZU drink and Korean BBQ burger. With a high rating of 4.5 stars, Shake Shack Herald Square continues to attract locals and tourists alike with its inviting atmosphere and delectable offerings.

Shake Shack Theater District#2
What stands out

  • The Shack Stack was somewhat decent enough to try, but the limited offerings like the Korean Style Fried Chicken Sandwich and the Korean BBQ Burger were disappointing. The service experience also did not meet expectations.

  • The veggie burger here is the best plant-based burger ever tasted, accompanied by tasty and crispy fries. A must-visit place for those looking for delicious burgers.

  • Great place for a quick lunch with fabulous cheesy fries, delicious burgers, chocolate shake, and refreshing mango passionfruit lemonade. The thick and delicious shakes are a highlight.

  • Good spot for a burger and fries, with tasty options for vegetarians. The veggie burger and mushroom burger were pleasing, and the service was efficient and quick.

Shake Shack Theater District

4.413,698 reviews
691 8th Ave, New York, NY 10036, United States

Shake Shack Theater District is a popular hamburger restaurant located in New York City, known for its delicious offerings and fast service. Customers can enjoy various dining options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in services. The restaurant is highly recommended for lunch, dinner, and even solo dining.

Shake Shack Madison Square Park#3
What stands out

  • The original shack burger is a timeless classic, although some customers feel that the standards may have slipped slightly over time.

  • The Portobello burger, shakes, and fries continue to receive praise for their quality and taste.

  • Customers appreciate the quick-moving line at noon, although seating can be a bit challenging during peak hours.

Shake Shack Madison Square Park

4.56,731 reviews
Madison Square Park, 23rd Street and, Madison Ave, New York, NY 10010, United States

Shake Shack Madison Square Park is a popular hamburger restaurant located in the heart of Madison Square Park in New York City. Known for its delicious burgers and fast service, this spot is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

The restaurant offers a range of service options including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. With a casual and trendy atmosphere, it is a great place to enjoy a meal with family, friends, or even solo. Additionally, the outdoor seating area is wheelchair-accessible, making it inclusive for all visitors.

With a solid rating of 4.5 and over 6700 reviews, Shake Shack Madison Square Park continues to be a go-to spot for those craving a delicious burger in a picturesque setting. Customer reviews highlight the outstanding food, friendly service, and overall enjoyable dining experience.

Ray's Candy Store#4
What stands out

  • A legend in the neighborhood, with a friendly and nostalgic atmosphere.

  • Delicious fried Oreos, with generous portions ideal for sharing.

  • Extensive menu including famous egg creams, beignets, nachos, and more.

  • Fast and friendly service, perfect for a quick visit or takeout.

Ray's Candy Store

4.71,107 reviews
113 Avenue A, New York, NY 10009, United States

Ray's Candy Store is a beloved Dessert shop in New York, offering a range of sweet treats that have captured the hearts of many. With a rating of 4.7, based on 1107 reviews, it's clear that customers are enamored with this establishment.

The reviews speak for themselves, highlighting not just the quality of the sweets but also the warmth and charm that Ray's Candy Store exudes. Whether it's the pistachio soft serve, egg creams, or deep fried Oreos, customers keep coming back for more. Don't miss out on this iconic spot in the East Village of Manhattan!

Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo#5
What stands out

  • Customers appreciate the great variety of burgers, wings, and shakes.

  • The staff is friendly, attentive, and creates a welcoming atmosphere.

  • Food portions are filling and satisfying, perfect for lunch or dinner.

  • Overall, the quality of the food, service, and ambiance receives high praise from visitors.

Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo

4.44,537 reviews
529 Broome St, New York, NY 10013, United States

Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo is a renowned hamburger restaurant located in New York. They offer a variety of services and features to enhance the dining experience of their customers. Some of the special highlights of this establishment include Outdoor seating, No-contact delivery, Great cocktails, Sport, and Fast service. Customers rave about their delicious food and amazing shakes.

Shake Shack Upper West Side#6
What stands out

  • The burger was good but small for the price, the Korean fries were a joke! Served cold and not really flavorful.

  • The hamburger is tasty but had a burnt patty, and the place is small with quick-moving queues.

  • The burgers are juicy, tasty, and come out quickly, although seating can be a challenge due to the crowds.

Shake Shack Upper West Side

4.37,743 reviews
366 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10024, United States

Shake Shack Upper West Side is a beloved hamburger restaurant that offers a range of service options including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. The establishment is known for its fast service and is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. It caters to various dietary needs with offerings like vegetarian options and serves comfort food along with alcohol, beer, and coffee.

Shake Shack Fulton Transit CTR - Manhattan#7
What stands out

  • Customers are impressed by the quality of the food, with some claiming that Shake Shack has now become their top choice for fast food burgers.

  • The frozen custard is highly recommended, and the shakes are always great.

  • Although the food can get somewhat pricey, customers find the experience solid and not overly crowded.

  • Some customers have commented on the speed of service and cleanliness of the location, hoping for improvements in these aspects.

Shake Shack Fulton Transit CTR - Manhattan

4.34,625 reviews
200 Broadway, Space LL2010 #2010, New York, NY 10038, United States

Shake Shack Fulton Transit CTR - Manhattan is a popular hamburger restaurant located in New York. Known for its delivery, takeaway, and dine-in services, this spot is a go-to for many looking for a quick and delicious meal. With an impressive rating of 4.3, customers rave about the quality of the food and the fast service provided.

Shake Shack Battery Park City#8
What stands out

  • The buns being dry and the fries lacking freshness

  • Disappointing chicken burgers with black lettuce and hard buns

  • Efficient service and good value for money

  • Delicious hamburgers, quick service, refillable drinks, and a great atmosphere

Shake Shack Battery Park City

4.33,502 reviews
215 Murray St, New York, NY 10282, United States

Shake Shack Battery Park City is a renowned Hamburger restaurant located in New York, US. Offering a wide range of services such as Outdoor seating, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in, this establishment aims to provide a seamless dining experience for its customers. Highlights of this restaurant include fast service, making it an ideal spot for those looking for a quick bite.

Customer reviews rave about the quality of the food and the efficiency of service. Some key points from the reviews include:

With a solid rating of 4.3 and over 3500 reviews, it's evident that Shake Shack Battery Park City is a popular choice for those craving delicious burgers in a casual and trendy environment. So, whether you're a local, a tourist, or a university student, this is a spot not to be missed!

Shake Shack Astor Place#9
What stands out

  • Delicious and flavorful burgers with great toppings and sides.

  • Modern atmosphere and attentive staff for a pleasant dining experience.

  • Convenient service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in.

Shake Shack Astor Place

4.32,130 reviews
20 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10003, United States

Shake Shack Astor Place is a popular hamburger restaurant located in New York, NY. Known for its juicy and flavorful burgers, this establishment offers a variety of toppings and sides that perfectly complement their main dishes. The modern atmosphere and attentive staff ensure a great dining experience for all customers. The services provided include delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options, making it convenient for everyone.

Customer reviews highlight the following key points:

It's not surprising that this restaurant has garnered a rating of 4.3 from 2130 reviews, making it a popular choice among burger lovers. If you're in the area, don't miss the opportunity to visit Shake Shack Astor Place and indulge in their mouthwatering offerings.

Shake Shack Grand Central Terminal#10
What stands out

  • The shack stack burger is packed with flavors and highly recommended. The price is reasonable for the portion size.

  • While there may be long lines and average fries, the brioche bun and tasty burger patties make it a worthwhile visit. The shakes are smooth and creamy.

  • One of the best burgers in NYC, featuring juicy smashburgers with a special sauce. Despite long queues, the service is quick

Shake Shack Grand Central Terminal

4.22,899 reviews
Lower Level Dining Concourse, 89 E 42nd St, New York, NY 10017, United States

Shake Shack Grand Central Terminal is a popular hamburger restaurant located in the heart of New York City. Offering takeaway, dine-in, and fast service, this spot is known for its delicious burgers and vegetarian options. Customers rave about the mouthwatering shack stack burger and the creamy cookies and cream shake. The casual and trendy atmosphere makes it a great spot for solo dining or meeting up with friends. While some reviews mention long lines, the quick service and scrumptious food make it worth the wait. Don't miss the opportunity to stop by Shake Shack Grand Central Terminal for a memorable dining experience!

Customer Reviews:

Shake Shack 1700 Broadway - 53rd & 7th#11
What stands out

  • "The best fast food with no discuss for ingredients quality, atmosphere, and brand identity, the shakes were crazy."

  • "Burgers are soooooo delicious. Fries are good, not great. The frozen hot chocolate milkshake special was ridiculous - so good it almost hurt. Don't skip Shake Shack!"

  • "I was astonished at how good a fast food burger could really be! The fries were nice and crisp, and the hibiscus caffeinated iced tea was a real treat."

  • "The Double Cheese Burger I ordered left me absolutely speechless."

Shake Shack 1700 Broadway - 53rd & 7th

4.22,021 reviews
1700 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, United States

Shake Shack 1700 Broadway - 53rd & 7th is a popular hamburger restaurant located in New York, NY. They offer a variety of services and features to enhance the dining experience. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The restaurant is known for its fast service and is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.2 stars, Shake Shack is praised for its delicious burgers and friendly atmosphere. Customers appreciate the quality of the food and the quick service provided. If you're in the area, don't miss out on Shake Shack's flavorful offerings!

Shake Shack Bryant Park#12
What stands out

  • Great burgers and delicious food

  • Busy atmosphere with friendly customer service

  • Clean premises with limited seating options

Shake Shack Bryant Park

4.2786 reviews
120 W 42nd St Suite-Retail C, New York, NY 10036, United States

Shake Shack Bryant Park is a popular hamburger restaurant located in New York, United States. The restaurant offers a variety of service options including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Known for its fast service, Shake Shack Bryant Park is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Customers have left positive reviews highlighting key points such as:

Whether you're looking for a quick bite, comfort food, or a casual dining experience, Shake Shack Bryant Park has something for everyone. With a rating of 4.2 and numerous positive reviews, it's no wonder why this burger joint is a must-visit in the area.

Kith Treats#13
What stands out

  • Great vibe and amazing treats

  • Unique concept with nostalgic cereals

  • Overpriced but delicious options

  • Large portions perfect for sharing

Kith Treats

4.574 reviews
337 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Kith Treats is an innovative ice cream shop located in New York, providing a unique experience for customers to enjoy delicious treats. The business offers various service options such as delivery, takeaway, and dining in. Customers can indulge in their favorite ice cream flavors mixed with a variety of cereals and toppings.

The store is known for its welcoming atmosphere and diverse selection of treats, making it a top choice for many. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Overall, guests are impressed by the quality and creativity of Kith Treats, making it a must-visit destination for ice cream lovers in the area.

Soft Swerve#14
What stands out

  • Unique selection of ice cream flavors

  • Great soft serve, especially the Thai iced tea ube swirl and black sesame flavors

  • Asian-inspired flavors like matcha and vietnamese coffee

  • Excellent customer service, with caring staff members

Soft Swerve

4.4126 reviews
379 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States

Soft Swerve is a popular ice cream shop located in New York City. They offer a variety of service options such as delivery, in-store shopping, and takeaway. Customers can enjoy their delicious soft serve ice cream with flavors like Thai tea, black sesame, ube, and more.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Customers have praised the quality and freshness of the ice cream at Soft Swerve. The pricing may be a bit on the higher side, but many find it worth the visit for the unique flavors and overall experience. If you're a fan of Asian-inspired desserts, Soft Swerve is definitely worth a visit!

Creamline#15
What stands out

  • Burgers were amazing, with some slight issues on sweet potato fries, but overall a great place for a quick bite with ample seating available.

  • Impressed by the sweet potato fries and buffalo chicken sandwich, prices are reasonable for a New York restaurant, highly recommended stop at Chelsea's Market.

  • Shakes offered a mix of flavors, thick and creamy texture, with some flavors standing out more than others due to personal taste preferences.

  • Outstanding Buffalo Chicken Sandwich, excellent seasonal spiked Peppermint shake, and exceptional hospitality from the owner/manager Nick, making it a must-visit place in Chelsea Market.

Creamline

3.9580 reviews
75 9th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States

Creamline is an American restaurant located in New York, NY. Offering delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options, this spot is known for its fast service and great dessert. Whether you're looking for a quick bite or a leisurely dining experience, Creamline has something for everyone. Customers have praised the burgers, sandwiches, and milkshakes served here.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

ShakeTop Milkshakes#16
What stands out

  • Awesome shakes and ice cream - a treat to look forward to!

  • This is not a real place, but the shakes are amazing - best milkshake ever!

ShakeTop Milkshakes

3.73 reviews
75 Montgomery St, New York, NY 10002, United States

ShakeTop Milkshakes is an ice cream shop located in New York, NY, offering a variety of delicious shakes and desserts. Customers can enjoy kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and takeaway options. The shop is family-friendly, LGBTQ+ friendly, and a transgender safe space, providing a welcoming atmosphere for all. They are known for their great desserts and quick service.

The shop has received a rating of 3.7 stars, with positive reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some key points from their reviews:

Experience the delicious treats at ShakeTop Milkshakes and satisfy your sweet cravings!

Summary

The comparison at a glance

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Shake Shack Herald Square 4.510,235
#2Shake Shack Theater District 4.413,698
#3Shake Shack Madison Square Park 4.56,731
#4Ray's Candy Store 4.71,107
#5Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer - SoHo 4.44,537
#6Shake Shack Upper West Side 4.37,743
#7Shake Shack Fulton Transit CTR - Manhattan 4.34,625
#8Shake Shack Battery Park City 4.33,502
#9Shake Shack Astor Place 4.32,130
#10Shake Shack Grand Central Terminal 4.22,899
#11Shake Shack 1700 Broadway - 53rd & 7th 4.22,021
#12Shake Shack Bryant Park 4.2786
#13Kith Treats 4.574
#14Soft Swerve 4.4126
#15Creamline 3.9580
#16ShakeTop Milkshakes 3.73

For businesses

Run a business?

Manage or add my business

Map and areas

Map of Milkshake Spots in New York

Craving a delicious milkshake in New York City but not sure where to start? Look no further! This map showcases all the best milkshake spots in the city, from trendy cafes to old-school diners. Whether you're in the mood for classic vanilla or a specialty flavor, this map will guide you to the perfect milkshake destination in the big apple.

How to choose Milkshake Spots in New York City

  1. Wide variety of flavors and toppings.
  2. Creaminess and thickness of the milkshake.
  3. Ambiance and location of the milkshake spot.
  4. Prices and sizes available.

Frequently asked questions

What makes milkshakes in New York so special?

In New York, milkshakes are known for their rich and creamy texture that is often made with high-quality ice cream sourced from local dairies. Many milkshake establishments in New York offer a wide variety of flavors, from classic vanilla and chocolate to innovative combinations like salted caramel and red velvet. Moreover, the presentation of milkshakes in New York often features indulgent toppings such as whipped cream, colorful sprinkles, and even whole cookies or brownies.

Where can I find the best milkshakes in New York?

New York City is home to numerous milkshake hotspots, from retro diners to trendy shake bars in Brooklyn and beyond. Some popular establishments known for their exceptional milkshakes include Black Tap Craft Burgers & Beer, Shake Shack, and Big Gay Ice Cream. Visitors to New York can also discover hidden gem milkshake places by exploring different neighborhoods and asking locals for recommendations.

Are there any unique milkshake flavors to try in New York?

Yes, New York City is teeming with creative milkshake flavors that cater to diverse palates and preferences. Adventurous milkshake enthusiasts can sample unique creations like matcha green tea, rosewater pistachio, and peanut butter banana shakes at specialty dessert shops. For those seeking a nostalgic treat, traditional milkshake flavors like black and white, s'mores, and malted milk are also popular choices in New York.

What are the typical prices for milkshakes in New York?

The cost of a milkshake in New York can vary depending on the establishment, location, and ingredients used. On average, a standard milkshake in New York may range from $5 to $10, while premium milkshakes with elaborate toppings or unique flavors could cost upwards of $15 to $20. It's advisable to check the menu or inquire with staff about milkshake prices before placing an order to avoid any surprises.

Related guides

The 16 Best Coffee in Brooklyn, New YorkThe 16 Best Pumpkin Pie in New York CityThe 16 Best Bloody Marys in New York City