Menu

How we pick places for our New York lists

How we choose places across the five boroughs: focus, a long-standing public reputation and what each business publishes. Nobody pays to be included.

New York never runs short of options. What most people lack is the time to sort through them, so each list narrows the field in a consistent way. First comes focus: a jazz club with music every night belongs ahead of a restaurant that books a trio on Sundays, and a pizzeria is measured against other pizzerias. Then comes reputation over time. We look at the public record of what customers think of a place, visible to anyone who searches for it, and read a strong rating in light of how long it has held, so a few weeks of buzz cannot outweigh many years of loyal regulars in Ridgewood or Bay Ridge.

Its own website and social accounts matter too, from the menu or services they list to how bookings work. The ranking that results is an editorial call made on merit. We revisit it regularly across all five boroughs, and readers can flag errors through our contact page. No one pays for inclusion or for a say in the criteria. Some places that earned a spot first go on to buy a fuller profile page or a promoted position, and those are always flagged.