Menu

New York City

The 16 Best Pumpkin Pie in New York City

For those craving the quintessential fall treat in the bustling metropolis of New York City, look no further than the delectable pumpkin pie. With numerous options scattered throughout the city, choosing the perfect slice can be a daunting task. Luckily, this comprehensive guide is here to help pie enthusiasts navigate their way through the best pumpkin pie in NYC.

Whether you prefer a traditional recipe with a flaky crust or a unique twist on this classic dessert, there is something for everyone in the Big Apple. From cozy bakeries to trendy cafes, each establishment offers its own take on the beloved pumpkin pie that is sure to satisfy even the most discerning palate.

Embark on a pumpkin pie tasting journey and discover The 16 Best Pumpkin Pie in New York City for a truly unforgettable culinary experience.

How this guide is ordered

Chosen by our New York editors from places across the five boroughs, giving weight to a long track record with locals, current opening details and how well each one delivers on what it promises. Lists are revisited often; tell us when a spot closes or moves.

Featured businesses may pay for a more visible position within the guide.

Top 3Full listMapHow to choose

Quick view

Featured options

Select an option to see its summary.

#1
Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe
4.64,554 reviews
#2
Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center
4.46,650 reviews
#3
Dominique Ansel Bakery
4.37,853 reviews

Full list

Compare 16 local options

Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe#1
What stands out

  • Everything in this place is simply WOW! Friendly staff, delicious cheesecake, and a charming ambiance make it a must-visit spot in NY.

  • The pastries here are always fresh, tasty, and made with the best ingredients. The service is top-notch, and the ambiance feels like a traditional Italian bakery.

  • This bakery is the best in town! With a variety of cakes to choose from, every option is delicious and worth trying.

Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe

4.64,554 reviews
342 E 11th St, New York, NY 10003, United States

Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe is a renowned bakery in New York that offers a wide array of delicious pastries, cakes, and desserts. Customers can enjoy No-contact delivery, Delivery, In-store pick-up, Takeaway, and Dine-in options. The bakery also provides Wheelchair-accessible entrance for those in need.

One of the key features of Veniero's is their delicious cheesecakes and cakes, which customers rave about. Here are some summarized customer reviews:

Overall, Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe has received high praise for its delectable desserts, excellent service, and inviting atmosphere. Their commitment to quality and customer satisfaction makes them a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center#2
What stands out

  • The banana pudding is a crowd favorite, with creamy texture and just the right amount of sweetness, topped with plenty of banana pieces.

  • Customers rave about the red velvet cake and the unique dark chocolate brownies.

  • Some customers have expressed disappointment in the carrot cake pudding batch, with reviews mentioning it being too sweet with not enough cake.

  • The cupcakes are highly recommended, described as phenomenal with a solid 10/10 score.

Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center

4.46,650 reviews
1240 6th Ave, New York, NY 10020, United States

Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center is a renowned Bakery located in New York. This bakery offers a variety of services and features, including Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, Takeaway, and Same-day delivery. Customers appreciate the Wheelchair-accessible entrance and Breakfast options available. The bakery is known for its famous banana pudding, red velvet cake, dark chocolate brownies, and carrot cake.

Dominique Ansel Bakery#3
What stands out

  • The Cronuts are a must-try, living up to the hype with their delightful flavors.

  • Customers rave about the DKA and the blossoming hot chocolate for their exceptional taste.

  • The staff is friendly, the atmosphere is welcoming, and the pastries are always fresh.

  • Visitors recommend the cookie cup with milk for its unique and enjoyable experience.

Dominique Ansel Bakery

4.37,853 reviews
189 Spring St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Dominique Ansel Bakery is a renowned Bakery located in New York City, providing a wide range of delectable pastries and treats. With a rating of 4.3, it's clear that customers absolutely love the offerings here.

Whether you're craving a classic croissant or a new and inventive treat, Dominique Ansel Bakery is the place to be. So be sure to stop by and indulge in some of the most exquisite pastries you'll ever taste!

Little Pie Company#4
What stands out

  • Desserts are good but pricey for the portions. Best macchiato. When you step in you’re greeted with the sweet smell of pie.

  • The bakers / check out people are really sweet and warmed up our pies to enjoy right there!

  • A nice neighborhood pie shop. It features a variety of pie, bread loafs, and drinks. The owner is there to make sure things are going accordingly to plan and mingle with the customers.

  • Came to little pie co around 7PM and they had a small selection of pies 50% off! All have been super delicious and I can’t wait to try some more pies

Little Pie Company

4.61,136 reviews
424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036, United States

Little Pie Company is a charming pie shop located in New York City. They offer a variety of delicious pies and desserts that are sure to satisfy any sweet tooth. Customers have raved about the friendly staff, cozy atmosphere, and the heavenly aroma of freshly baked pies that greets you as you enter. If you're looking for a quick visit or a cozy spot to enjoy some great food, Little Pie Company is the place to be.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie#5
What stands out

  • Top 3 Key Lime Pie in New York with excellent flavor of the pie crust and smooth Key Lime flavor.

  • The best Key Lime Pie north of Key Largo, authentic and delicious.

  • Great key lime pie with a view of the Statue of Liberty, flavors were on point.

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

4.7645 reviews
185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, United States

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is a renowned pie shop located in Brooklyn, NY. They offer a variety of services including delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and same-day delivery. Customers can enjoy the delicious Key Lime Pie that has garnered rave reviews. Some key points from customer reviews include:

These positive experiences highlight the quality and authenticity of the Key Lime Pies available at Steve's. Customers also appreciate the women-owned aspect of this business, making it a favorite spot for pie lovers in the area. Stop by Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie to indulge in a slice of Key Lime perfection!

Petee's Pie Company#6
What stands out

  • Customers praise the friendly staff who are knowledgeable about the different pie options.

  • The crust-to-filling ratio is spot-on, making every bite a delight.

  • Many guests highlight the richness and aroma of the pies, with flavors that stand out.

  • The variety of flavors available ensures that there is something for everyone's taste preference.

Petee's Pie Company

4.6907 reviews
61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002, United States

Petee's Pie Company is a renowned pie shop located in New York, NY. This establishment offers a variety of pie flavors that customers rave about. Some of the customer favorites include the Keylime pie, coconut and blueberry crumble pie, Brown Butter Honey Pecan pie, and the chocolate cream pie. Customers particularly appreciate the perfect balance of flavors in each slice, from the crust to the filling.

Visit the Petee's Pie Company to indulge in a delightful pie experience that will surely leave you craving for more.

Pies 'n' Thighs#7
What stands out

  • Delicious fried chicken and waffles with blueberry preserves

  • Amazing honey butter biscuits and flavorful mac & cheese

  • Highly recommended pies, especially the banana cream pie

  • Great service, relaxed atmosphere, and a wide variety of menu options

Pies 'n' Thighs

4.33,330 reviews
166 S 4th St, Brooklyn, NY 11211, United States

Pies 'n' Thighs is a beloved Southern restaurant in Brooklyn, NY, known for its delicious comfort food and exceptional service. The restaurant offers a variety of dining options, including breakfast, lunch, and dinner, making it a popular choice for solo diners and groups alike.

The highlights of this establishment include fast service, great coffee, and great desserts. Customers rave about the chicken biscuit, cheese grits, and pecan donut. The cozy and casual atmosphere makes it a great spot for families, LGBTQ+ individuals, and university students.

Customer reviews praise the restaurant for its tasty food and excellent service. Some key points from reviews include:

Overall, Pies 'n' Thighs is a must-visit dining destination for those craving authentic Southern flavors and a welcoming dining experience.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds#8
What stands out

  • The pies are incredibly delicious, especially the Lemon Chess Pie and the Salted Caramel Apple.

  • The staff is described as kind and welcoming, contributing to a pleasant experience.

  • The atmosphere is highlighted for being charming and rustic, with plenty of seating available.

  • The selection of pies, including flavors like matcha, honey lavender, and apple pie, is highly recommended.

Four & Twenty Blackbirds

4.5800 reviews
439 3rd Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11215, United States

Four & Twenty Blackbirds is a renowned pie shop located in Brooklyn, NY. This establishment offers a variety of services, including delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and even dine-in options. Customers appreciate the wi-fi availability and the LGBTQ+ friendly atmosphere.

With a rating of 4.5 stars based on 800 reviews, Four & Twenty Blackbirds has garnered positive feedback from its customers. Some key points from the reviews include:

Overall, Four & Twenty Blackbirds stands out for its delicious pies, cozy atmosphere, and friendly service, making it a must-visit spot for pie enthusiasts in Brooklyn.

Abu's Homestyle Bakery#9
What stands out

  • The taste of the pies is unbeatable, but the delivery and customer service left much to be desired.

  • Despite the delicious products, long wait times and lackluster customer service experiences have left some customers hesitant to return.

  • The sweet potato pies are so good that customers find themselves craving them and reminiscing about family gatherings.

  • Weekly customers praise the bean pies and the exceptional customer service they receive with every visit.

Abu's Homestyle Bakery

4.5208 reviews
1184 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY 11216, United States

Abu's Homestyle Bakery is a beloved bakery that offers a variety of delicious treats at 1184 Fulton St, Brooklyn, NY. Customers can enjoy delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway options, ensuring that they can enjoy their favorite pastries with ease.

One key feature of Abu's Homestyle Bakery is its wheelchair-accessible entrance, making it a welcoming place for all customers. Whether you're stopping in for a quick visit or planning to spend some time browsing the selection, Abu's has you covered.

Customers rave about the delectable pies available at Abu's Homestyle Bakery. Some key points from their reviews include:

With a rating of 4.5 stars and over 200 reviews, Abu's Homestyle Bakery continues to be a favorite spot for anyone with a sweet tooth in Brooklyn. Visit their website at abusbakery.com or give them a call at +1 718-230-1115 to satisfy your cravings for delicious baked goods.

Allen's Pie LLC#10
What stands out

  • Allen's pies are amazing, with the perfect apple to crust ratio.

  • Customers love the cherry pie and find the pies to be satisfying without feeling stuffed.

  • The buttery crust and stuffed filling make these personal-sized pies a hit for any occasion.

  • Customers consider Allen's pies to be the best they've ever had, with impeccable customer service and fast delivery.

Allen's Pie LLC

5.013 reviews
nan

Allen's Pie LLC is a beloved pie shop that has captured the hearts of many customers with its delectable pies. The business offers no-contact delivery and a wide variety of flavors to choose from. Customers rave about Allen's pies, praising them for being consistently delicious and perfectly sized. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Kerber's Farm NYC#11
What stands out

  • Delicious pies with balanced flavors and textures

  • Great ambiance and friendly staff

  • High-quality baked goods, like blueberry muffins and savory pies

  • Beautiful interior with a touch of country charm

Kerber's Farm NYC

4.753 reviews
264 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10014, United States

Kerber's Farm NYC is a charming bakery located in New York. With a rating of 4.7, this bakery offers a variety of delightful treats that keep customers coming back for more. Customers have praised Kerber's Farm NYC for several key points:

Whether you're looking for a quick visit or a cozy place to enjoy a cup of coffee, Kerber's Farm NYC has you covered. Make sure to stop by and indulge in their scrumptious offerings!

Dominique Ansel Workshop#12
What stands out

  • Customers praised the fresh and amazing taste of the baked goods, with particular highlights on the chocolate hazelnut with Earl Grey twists and ham and cheese croissants.

  • Visitors were impressed by the helpful and patient service provided by the staff, making their experience enjoyable and memorable.

  • Although some reviews noted slight consistency issues with certain items, overall, the bakery received high ratings for its creativity and quality in pastry-making.

  • Customers appreciated the variety of items available, from savory to sweet, making it a great spot for a quick visit and a delightful treat.

Dominique Ansel Workshop

4.3355 reviews
17 E 27th St, New York, NY 10016, United States

Dominique Ansel Workshop is a renowned bakery located in New York City. Their diverse service options include delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, takeaway, and same-day delivery. Customers can enjoy a delicious breakfast at this establishment, known for its exquisite pastries and baked goods.

The bakery has received numerous positive reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some key points based on their feedback:

With a rating of 4.3 stars and over 355 reviews, Dominique Ansel Workshop continues to captivate customers with its innovative pastries and exceptional service. Visit their website or stop by to savor the delightful creations this bakery has to offer.

Fancy Pies#13
What stands out

  • Working with Fancy Pies was an absolute pleasure, with exceptional service and delicious pies that added charm to the event.

  • The Jamaica Spiced Pumpkin and Southern Bourbon Pecan pies are bursting with rich flavors, making them household favorites.

  • Every pie from Fancy Pies is made with love and delivers fantastic taste, converting even those who don't typically enjoy pies.

  • The maple walnut pie was a hit for Thanksgiving, featuring a flavorful filling and a perfect crust that received high praise from guests.

Fancy Pies

4.913 reviews
2236 Adam Clayton Powell Jr Blvd, New York, NY 10027, United States

Fancy Pies is a charming bakery located in New York that offers a delightful array of pies and exceptional service. Customers rave about the delicious pies and the elegant touch they bring to events. The cherry pies with heart-shaped cutouts of pie crust are a favorite among guests, who couldn't stop raving about them. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a 4.9 rating, Fancy Pies is highly recommended for those looking for top-notch pies and exceptional customer satisfaction. Whether you're celebrating a special occasion or simply craving a tasty dessert treat, Fancy Pies is the place to visit.

Pie Corps#14
What stands out

  • A customer described the shop as adorable and industrial with delicious pies and friendly service.

  • An enthusiastic patron praised the quality of the bacon egg and cheese sandwich and other hand pies.

  • Another visitor raved about the Chocolate Maple Pecan Pie and refreshing lemonades, as well as the helpful staff.

Pie Corps

4.2147 reviews
77 Driggs Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11222, United States

Pie Corps is a charming pie shop located in Brooklyn, NY. The shop offers a variety of delicious pies, including double chocolate, apple, key lime, and more. Customers can enjoy options like kerbside pickup and in-store shopping. The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make it a delightful place to visit.

Posh Pop Bakeshop#15
What stands out

  • Customers rave about the mouthwatering desserts, with options like Ube Cheesecake, Ube Velvet Cake, and divine Tres Leches.

  • Many patrons appreciate the cozy ambiance and friendly staff, making every visit a delightful experience.

  • With an array of baked goods such as donuts, cake pops, churros, and cupcakes, Posh Pop Bakeshop is a dream come true for those with a sweet tooth.

  • A clear labeling system for allergens ensures that everyone can enjoy these scrumptious treats without worry.

Posh Pop Bakeshop

3.9622 reviews
192 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Posh Pop Bakeshop is a charming bakery nestled in the heart of New York City. This women-owned establishment offers a wide range of delectable treats, including cakes, cookies, cinnamon rolls, and more, all deliciously gluten-free.

Whether you're stopping by for a quick visit or planning a leisurely dessert indulgence, Posh Pop Bakeshop is sure to satisfy your cravings. Visit their website to explore their menu and place an order today!

PLocal option
#16
What stands out

  • Small slices, lacking flavor and heavily salted.

  • Stingy portion sizes compared to the price.

  • Reliably delicious pies with great quality and freshness.

  • Disorganized experience for prepaid orders on Thanksgiving eve.

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market

3.612 reviews
600 11th Ave, New York, NY 10036, United States

Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market is a delightful pie shop located in New York, offering a variety of delicious pies. Customers can enjoy delivery or takeaway options, making it convenient for pie lovers on the go.

The cozy atmosphere and friendly staff make the experience at Petee’s Pie Company truly special. With a rating of 3.6, this shop has captured the hearts of many customers. Here are a few key points from their reviews:

Whether you're in the mood for a classic pie or a seasonal flavor, Petee’s Pie Company is sure to satisfy your cravings. Visit their website to place your order or stop by during their operating hours for a quick visit.

Summary

The comparison at a glance

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Veniero's Pasticceria & Caffe 4.64,554
#2Magnolia Bakery - Rockefeller Center 4.46,650
#3Dominique Ansel Bakery 4.37,853
#4Little Pie Company 4.61,136
#5Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie 4.7645
#6Petee's Pie Company 4.6907
#7Pies 'n' Thighs 4.33,330
#8Four & Twenty Blackbirds 4.5800
#9Abu's Homestyle Bakery 4.5208
#10Allen's Pie LLC 5.013
#11Kerber's Farm NYC 4.753
#12Dominique Ansel Workshop 4.3355
#13Fancy Pies 4.913
#14Pie Corps 4.2147
#15Posh Pop Bakeshop 3.9622
#16Petee’s Pie Company at Gotham West Market 3.612

For businesses

Run a business?

Manage or add my business

Map and areas

Map of Pumpkin Pie in New York City

Indulge in a pumpkin pie adventure in New York City with this comprehensive map of all the best pumpkin pie spots in the city. From classic bakeries to trendy cafes, satisfy your cravings for this fall favorite treat at any of these delicious locations. Don't miss out on trying some of the most delectable pumpkin pies NYC has to offer!

How to choose Pumpkin Pie in New York City

  1. Various bakeries and cafes to choose from.
  2. Different styles of pumpkin pie available.
  3. Prices and portions vary by location.
  4. Quality of ingredients used in each pie.

Frequently asked questions

What makes pumpkin pie so popular in New York?

Pumpkin pie is a traditional dessert during the fall season, and in New York City, it has become a beloved staple thanks to its delicious combination of spices and smooth texture. Many bakeries and restaurants in the city offer their own twists on the classic recipe, using high-quality ingredients and innovative techniques to create decadent and memorable pumpkin pies. New Yorkers also enjoy pumpkin pie as a nostalgic treat that reminds them of cozy gatherings with friends and family, especially during holidays like Thanksgiving and Christmas.

Where can I find the best pumpkin pies in New York City?

There are numerous bakeries and cafes in New York City that are known for their exceptional pumpkin pies, including iconic establishments like Magnolia Bakery and Four & Twenty Blackbirds. For a more unique take on pumpkin pie, you can visit artisanal bakeries like Milk Bar and Pie Corps, where you can find innovative flavors and creative presentations. Many farmers' markets and food festivals in the city also feature local bakers and pastry chefs who specialize in handcrafted pumpkin pies made with fresh, seasonal ingredients.

How can I make a homemade pumpkin pie in New York City?

To make a delicious homemade pumpkin pie in New York City, you can visit specialty stores like Sahadi's in Brooklyn or Zabar's on the Upper West Side to find high-quality pie crusts and pumpkin puree. Follow a classic pumpkin pie recipe that includes ingredients like canned pumpkin, sweetened condensed milk, eggs, and a mix of spices like cinnamon, nutmeg, and cloves. You can also experiment with different variations of pumpkin pie, such as adding a streusel topping, incorporating chocolate chips or pecans, or making mini pies for easy serving and sharing.

What are some tips for baking the perfect pumpkin pie in New York City?

Ensure that your pie crust is properly chilled before adding the pumpkin filling to prevent it from becoming soggy during baking. Blind bake your pie crust before adding the pumpkin filling to ensure a crispy and flaky texture. For a smooth and creamy texture, mix the pumpkin pie filling ingredients thoroughly and avoid overmixing to prevent air bubbles from forming. Bake your pumpkin pie at a low temperature for a longer period to prevent the filling from cracking or overbaking, and allow it to cool completely before serving for the best flavor and texture.

Related guides

The 16 Best Bloody Marys in New York CityThe 16 Best Bubble Tea in New YorkThe 11 Best Slice New York