Menu

New York City

The 4 Best Macaroni and Cheese in New York City

When it comes to comfort food, few dishes can rival the creamy and indulgent goodness of macaroni and cheese. Whether you're a local New Yorker or just passing through, there's something special about enjoying a warm and gooey bowl of mac and cheese in the heart of the New York City.

For those on the hunt for the best macaroni and cheese in New York City, look no further. This list compiles the top contenders in the city, each offering their own unique take on this classic dish. Whether you prefer your mac and cheese baked to perfection or topped with decadent truffle oil, there's a spot in NYC that will satisfy your cravings.

Now, without further ado, here are The 4 Best Macaroni and Cheese in New York City. Get ready to embark on a cheesy journey through the streets of the Big Apple!

How this guide is ordered

Chosen by our New York editors from places across the five boroughs, giving weight to a long track record with locals, current opening details and how well each one delivers on what it promises. Lists are revisited often; tell us when a spot closes or moves.

Featured businesses may pay for a more visible position within the guide.

Top 3Full listMapHow to choose

Quick view

Featured options

Select an option to see its summary.

#1
Jacob's Pickles
4.66,022 reviews
#2
S'MAC East Village
4.52,710 reviews
#3
Schnipper's
4.23,630 reviews

Full list

Compare 4 local options

Jacob's Pickles#1
What stands out

  • The food was absolutely delicious with quick service and fresh dishes.

  • Generous portions and great value for money, perfect for Southern food lovers.

  • Warm atmosphere and friendly staff make dining a memorable experience.

  • Diverse menu with classic Southern favorites and an extensive drink selection.

Jacob's Pickles

4.66,022 reviews
509 Amsterdam Ave, New York, NY 10024, United States

Jacob's Pickles is a beloved Southern restaurant in New York known for its delicious comfort food and warm atmosphere. Customers rave about the fast service, generous portions, and diverse menu of classic Southern dishes. Some of the popular items include devil eggs, biscuits, fried chicken Caesar salad, hot chicken biscuits, meatloaf, and more. Customers also appreciate the cozy and trendy atmosphere, making it a perfect spot for solo dining or casual gatherings. The restaurant offers a range of services like outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in to cater to various preferences. With a rating of 4.6 from over 6000 reviews, Jacob's Pickles continues to impress locals and visitors alike.

S'MAC East Village#2
What stands out

  • Customers appreciate the variety of flavors available.

  • The quick service and cozy atmosphere have been highlighted as positives.

  • Visitors recommend checking out the skillets hanging on the wall to gauge portion sizes.

S'MAC East Village

4.52,710 reviews
197 1st Ave., New York, NY 10003, United States

S'MAC East Village is an American restaurant located in New York, NY, known for its delectable mac and cheese dishes. The restaurant offers a variety of options, including meat and vegetarian dishes, with quick service and a cozy atmosphere. Customers have raved about the flavorful mac and cheese, with options such as buffalo mac and cheese and vegan mac receiving high praise.

Schnipper's#3
What stands out

  • Great food at reasonable prices

  • Fast and good service with helpful recommendations

  • Super creamy Mac and Cheese and friendly staff

  • Gluten free options and delicious bacon BLT sandwich

Schnipper's

4.23,630 reviews
620 8th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States

Schnipper's is a popular American restaurant located in New York City. The restaurant offers a variety of service options including outdoor seating, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy fast service and a menu that is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

Some key points from customer reviews include:

With a solid rating of 4.2 and over 3600 reviews, Schnipper's is a go-to spot for a quick and tasty meal in the bustling city. If you're in the area and craving some delicious comfort food, Schnipper's is the place to be!

Melt Shop#4
What stands out

  • Great food variety

  • Good value for the price

  • Excellent customer service

Melt Shop

4.31,171 reviews
135 W 50th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

Melt Shop is a popular restaurant located in New York, known for its delicious grilled cheese options. With a rating of 4.3 stars based on 1171 reviews, customers have shared their experiences:

One customer mentioned, "The chicken is good, but the portions could be better for the price." Another customer praised the staff, saying, "The staff here were great!"

Melt Shop offers service options such as delivery, takeaway, and dine-in, making it convenient for customers to enjoy their meals. The highlights include fast service, while it is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. The restaurant is known for its comfort food offerings and has a casual atmosphere.

If you find yourself near Times Square and craving a tasty grilled cheese sandwich, Melt Shop is the place to go!

Summary

The comparison at a glance

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Jacob's Pickles 4.66,022
#2S'MAC East Village 4.52,710
#3Schnipper's 4.23,630
#4Melt Shop 4.31,171

For businesses

Run a business?

Manage or add my business

Map and areas

Map of Macaroni and Cheese in New York City

Craving comfort food in the Big Apple? Look no further than our map of all the best macaroni and cheese spots in New York City. From gourmet twists on the classic dish to homestyle favorites, this guide will lead you to cheesy goodness in every borough. Get ready to indulge in creamy, gooey goodness across the city that never sleeps.

How to choose Macaroni and Cheese in New York City

  1. Location: proximity to your current location.
  2. Price: affordability and value for money.
  3. Ingredients: quality and variety of cheeses used.
  4. Reviews: ratings and feedback from other customers.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I find the best macaroni and cheese in New York City?

If you're looking for the best macaroni and cheese in New York City, consider trying out S'mac or Macbar. These popular spots are known for their delicious and creamy mac and cheese dishes that are sure to satisfy your cravings. Another great option is Murray's Cheese Bar, which offers a gourmet twist on the classic mac and cheese. Their menu features a variety of cheeses and toppings that will take your mac and cheese experience to the next level. For a more casual setting, you can also visit Root & Bone or Jacob's Pickles for a comforting and flavorful macaroni and cheese dish that will leave you coming back for more.

Is there a macaroni and cheese festival in New York City?

Yes, New York City hosts an annual Macaroni and Cheese Festival where you can sample a wide variety of mac and cheese dishes from different vendors and restaurants in the city. This festival is a great way to celebrate your love for macaroni and cheese and discover new and innovative takes on this classic comfort food. Keep an eye out for announcements about the next Macaroni and Cheese Festival in New York City and make sure to get your tickets early as this event tends to sell out quickly.

What are some unique macaroni and cheese dishes to try in New York City?

If you're looking to step outside the traditional mac and cheese box, New York City has plenty of unique and creative options for you to try. One popular choice is the Truffle Mac and Cheese, which adds a touch of luxury to this classic dish with the addition of truffle oil or truffle shavings. Another unique option is the Buffalo Chicken Mac and Cheese, which combines the spicy flavors of buffalo chicken with the creamy goodness of mac and cheese for a delicious and satisfying meal. If you're feeling adventurous, you can also try the Lobster Mac and Cheese, which features chunks of fresh lobster meat mixed into the cheesy pasta for a decadent and indulgent twist on the classic macaroni and cheese.

Are there any vegan or gluten-free options for macaroni and cheese in New York City?

Yes, New York City is known for its diverse culinary scene, which includes options for those with dietary restrictions. If you're looking for vegan macaroni and cheese, you can try restaurants like Champs Diner or Urban Vegan Kitchen, which offer delicious plant-based versions of this classic comfort food. For gluten-free options, consider visiting Risotteria Melotti or Friedman's, where you can enjoy gluten-free mac and cheese dishes without sacrificing flavor or quality. Make sure to check with the restaurant beforehand to ensure that they can accommodate your dietary needs and preferences.

Related guides

The 19 Best Gluten-Free Pizza Restaurants in New York CityThe 16 Best Sicilian Pizza in New YorkThe 16 Best Biryani in New York