Menu

The 16 Best Sicilian Pizza in New York

When it comes to authentic Sicilian pizza in New York, there is no shortage of options to choose from. Whether you're a local looking for a new favorite spot or a visitor wanting to experience the iconic flavors of the Big Apple, this city has something for everyone.

From traditional pizzerias to trendy eateries, New York offers a diverse array of Sicilian pizza establishments. Each venue brings its own unique twist to this classic dish, making the decision of where to indulge in a slice even more difficult.

Before you dive into the search for the perfect slice of Sicilian pizza in New York, take a look at this curated list of the best places to satisfy your cravings in the city.

How this guide is ordered

Chosen by our New York editors from places across the five boroughs, giving weight to a long track record with locals, current opening details and how well each one delivers on what it promises. Lists are revisited often; tell us when a spot closes or moves.

Featured businesses may pay for a more visible position within the guide.

Top 3Full listMapHow to choose

Compare 16 local options

JLocal option
#1
What stands out
  • Authentic New York-style pizza experience with perfect crust and flavorful toppings.

  • Enjoyable atmosphere that captures the essence of classic pizza joints.

  • Long lines and wait times are worth the exceptional taste and quality of the pizza.

  • Convenient location and popular spot for a quick, satisfying meal.

Joe's Pizza

4.58,508 reviews
7 Carmine St, New York, NY 10014, United States

Joe's Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant located in New York, offering a variety of services to its customers. Known for its fast service and popular for both lunch and dinner, this place caters to tourists and university students alike. Customers can enjoy delivery, takeaway, or dine-in options, with a range of comfort food and late-night bites available.

Customer reviews rave about the delicious New York-style pizza served at Joe's Pizza. Key points from the reviews include:

Whether you're a pizza aficionado or just looking for a tasty bite, Joe's Pizza is a must-visit spot in New York City for an unforgettable pizza experience.

Joe’s Pizza#2
What stands out
  • The aroma of freshly baked pizza fills the air upon entering, setting the stage for a delightful experience.

  • The pizza itself is described as flavorful, perfectly cooked, and just the right amount of greasy goodness.

  • The crust is thin and crispy, the sauce tangy and flavorful, and the cheese gooey and evenly distributed.

  • Quality ingredients and the overall positive experience make Joe’s Pizza stand out among other pizza places.

Joe’s Pizza

4.64,354 reviews
124 Fulton St, New York, NY 10038, United States

Joe’s Pizza is a well-known pizza restaurant located in the heart of New York City. Known for its traditional New York-style slices, Joe’s Pizza offers a delightful experience to pizza lovers. The cozy and bustling ambiance adds to the authenticity of the place, making it a must-visit spot for locals and tourists.

Some key points from customer reviews:

Whether you're in the mood for a classic cheese slice or craving a specialty pizza loaded with toppings, Joe’s Pizza has got you covered. The efficient and friendly service ensures that customers feel welcome and well taken care of. So, if you're looking for an authentic slice of NYC with a side of celebrity history, Joe’s Pizza is the spot to be!

Uncle Sam's Pizza#3
What stands out
  • Delicious slices that are some of the best in the city

  • Exceptional dining experience with friendly service and authentic New York ambiance

  • Divine pizzas with perfectly crispy crusts and generous toppings

Uncle Sam's Pizza

4.81,059 reviews
17 Clinton St, New York, NY 10002, United States

Uncle Sam's Pizza is a beloved Pizza restaurant located in New York City, offering a wide range of services to cater to all pizza lovers. Customers can enjoy options such as Outdoor seating, Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in to fit their preferences.

This bustling pizzeria is known for its fast service, making it a go-to spot for those looking for a quick and tasty meal. Whether you're stopping by for Lunch, Dinner, or even dining solo, Uncle Sam's Pizza has something for everyone.

Customers rave about their experience at Uncle Sam's Pizza. Some key points from reviews include:

So, if you're in the mood for top-notch pizza with a casual atmosphere, Uncle Sam's Pizza is the place to be!

Song' E Napule#4
What stands out
  • Exceptional food quality and flavors

  • Efficient and courteous service

  • Lively and welcoming atmosphere

Song' E Napule

4.71,801 reviews
146 W Houston St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Song' E Napule is a renowned pizza restaurant in New York that has garnered rave reviews from customers. The restaurant offers a variety of service options including outdoor seating, delivery, and dine-in, making it a versatile choice for all dining preferences.

One of the highlights of this restaurant is its fast service, ensuring that customers are promptly served with delicious, fresh dishes. It is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining, catering to a wide range of dining occasions.

Customers have praised Song' E Napule for its exceptional food and service. Reviews highlight the insanely good meatballs and Montanara pizza, the top-notch quality servers, and the lively atmosphere. The pizzaiolo's world championship win adds to the restaurant's allure, cementing its status as one of the top 10 in the US.

In summary, customers have emphasized the following key points in their reviews:

Sicily Osteria#5
What stands out
  • One customer praised the restaurant for its warm atmosphere, attentive service, and delicious food, making it their new favorite Italian spot.

  • Another customer found the overall experience to be pleasant but not exceptionally memorable, with some dishes lacking flavor.

  • A different customer appreciated the consistent quality of the food, kind service, and variety of mocktail options, perfect for a quick bite between shows.

  • One customer described the restaurant as a hidden gem on Restaurant Row, highlighting the fantastic food, service, and atmosphere, giving it a glowing recommendation.

Sicily Osteria

4.71,505 reviews
330 W 46th St, New York, NY 10036, United States

Sicily Osteria is a charming Italian restaurant located in New York City. They offer a variety of services and features such as outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Customers rave about the fast service and great dessert selections.

Here are some summarized customer reviews:

Vito's Slices and Ices#6
What stands out
  • The crust perfectly done, the garlic knots buttery and crispy, making it true NYC pizza.

  • Always a good selection available with fresh, fantastic pizza and small pepperoni slices.

  • Simple but delicious topping options like Marguerita, Upside Down, and Grandma pizza.

  • Amazing slices with a fluffy, crispy, and chewy dough that is truly a revelation.

Vito's Slices and Ices

4.71,170 reviews
464 9th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States

Vito's Slices and Ices is a popular pizza restaurant located in New York City. This spot is known for its delicious pizza slices and refreshing Italian ices. Customers can enjoy a variety of service options including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Vito's is a great choice for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

With a rating of 4.7 based on 1170 reviews, Vito's Slices and Ices is highly recommended by customers. They appreciate the friendly staff, delicious pizza, and cozy atmosphere offered at this establishment. Whether you're a local resident or a tourist, Vito's should definitely be on your list of places to visit in the city.

PLocal option
#7
What stands out
  • Customers praise the exceptional quality of the food, especially highlighting dishes like roasted veal, zucchini flowers, and agnolotti.

  • Guests appreciate the perfect service and lovely ambience that make dining at Piccola Cucina a memorable experience.

  • Many reviewers mention the authenticity of the Italian cuisine offered, along with the freshness and flavor of each dish.

Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana

4.61,903 reviews
196 Spring St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana is a charming Italian restaurant located in New York. This cozy spot offers a variety of services, including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Customers rave about the fast service, great coffee, and great dessert selections.

John's Pizzeria of Times Square#8
What stands out
  • Portions are shareable size, best Caesar salad ever.

  • Pizza's are enormous and ideal for sharing, staff is friendly and helpful.

  • Great service, delicious pizza, and a unique atmosphere in a former church building.

  • Historic ambiance, charming setting, and friendly service make it a standout dining destination.

John's Pizzeria of Times Square

4.37,017 reviews
260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, United States

John's Pizzeria of Times Square is a renowned pizza restaurant located in the heart of New York City. This establishment is highly recommended for its fast service and is a popular choice for both lunch and dinner. Visitors can enjoy a quintessential New York City dining experience with historic ambiance and delectable pizza.

Some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.3 based on 7017 reviews, it is evident that John's Pizzeria of Times Square is a top choice for locals and tourists alike. Experience the charm of this establishment and indulge in authentic New York-style pizza like never before.

Norma Hell's Kitchen#9
What stands out
  • Authentic Italian cuisine, flavorful dishes, and efficient service with a cozy atmosphere.

  • Delicious and fresh menu items, quick and friendly service, perfect for pre or post-Broadway show meals.

  • REAL Sicilian food, prepared like a grandmother would, reasonable prices, ample portions, and friendly staff.

  • Great Italian spot in the city, nice atmosphere, affordable prices, generous portion sizes, and fresh ingredients.

Norma Hell's Kitchen

4.6667 reviews
801 9th Ave, New York, NY 10019, United States

Norma Hell's Kitchen is a renowned Sicilian restaurant located in New York City. With a rating of 4.6, it's a favorite among locals and tourists alike. The restaurant offers various service options including outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Fast service is one of the highlights of the place, making it perfect for a quick meal.

Customers rave about their experience at Norma Hell's Kitchen. Here are some key points from their reviews:

If you're looking for a taste of Sicily in the heart of New York City, Norma Hell's Kitchen is the place to be!

Artichoke Basille's Pizza#10
What stands out
  • Large and delicious slices, perfect for sharing

  • Wide selection of toppings and friendly staff

  • Highly recommended vodka slice and unique artichoke pizza

Artichoke Basille's Pizza

4.32,936 reviews
321 E 14th St, New York, NY 10003, United States

Artichoke Basille's Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant in New York known for its delicious slices and fast service. Customers can enjoy a variety of options such as no-contact delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. The restaurant is popular for lunch and dinner, making it suitable for solo dining or a quick bite. Despite not having wheelchair-accessible options, the restaurant offers vegetarian and comfort food options, along with alcohol and beer choices.

With a rating of 4.3 and over 2900 reviews, the restaurant has garnered positive feedback from customers. Some key points highlighted by reviewers include:

So, whether you're a tourist, university student, or local resident, Artichoke Basille's Pizza welcomes you to experience their fantastic pizza offerings!

Famous Famiglia Pizza#11
What stands out
  • Delicious pizza in the heart of NYC with the perfect crust-to-cheese ratio. A must-visit for pizza lovers.

  • Warm, fresh, and cozy atmosphere with friendly staff. A true Italian pizza parlor experience.

  • Friendly service with average food quality. Good for a quick and inexpensive meal in Times Square.

  • Outstanding service with delicious food. Exceptional experience with smiling and welcoming staff.

Famous Famiglia Pizza

4.41,316 reviews
686 8th Ave, New York, NY 10036, United States

Famous Famiglia Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant located in the heart of New York City. They offer a variety of service options such as Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. This spot is popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining, making it a great choice for any time of day. The restaurant provides comfort food, late-night food, quick bites, and small plates to cater to various preferences.

Customers rave about their experience at Famous Famiglia Pizza. Here are some summarized reviews:

Siena Pizza#12
What stands out
  • Customers rave about the great food and kind service, with delicious buffalo chicken and pepperoni pizza options.

  • The authentic pizzeria vibe and crispy, flavorsome NY-style pizza receive high praise from patrons.

  • Visitors recommend Siena Pizza as a must-visit spot for any pizza lover, highlighting the unique atmosphere and exceptional quality of pizzas.

Siena Pizza

4.5637 reviews
14 Rector St, New York, NY 10006, United States

Siena Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant located in New York, offering a wide range of services and features to cater to different preferences. Customers can enjoy no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The restaurant is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining, making it a versatile choice for various occasions.

The establishment prides itself on being accessible with a wheelchair-accessible entrance for all patrons. Customers can indulge in comfort food, late-night food, quick bites, and small plates from their diverse offerings. The dining options include breakfast, lunch, dinner, and dessert, ensuring a satisfying culinary experience throughout the day.

With a casual and cozy atmosphere, Siena Pizza attracts a diverse crowd, including both locals and tourists. The restaurant accepts various payment options like credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments, making transactions convenient for all diners. Families with children can also enjoy a visit as the establishment is good for kids.

Don Filippo#13
What stands out
  • Great lunch deal with 2 slices and a drink

  • Decent spot for a quick bite, but service can be friendlier

  • Good pizza options like margarita and grandma

  • Delicious pizza and Italian food, with excellent customer service

Don Filippo

4.4716 reviews
1133 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10075, United States

Don Filippo is a well-loved pizza restaurant located in New York City. They offer a variety of service options, including kerbside pickup, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers appreciate their fast service and rave about their delicious food.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.4 and numerous positive reviews, Don Filippo is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area. Visit their website for more information and stop by to enjoy a delightful dining experience!

SLocal option
#14

Sicily's Best

4.5171 reviews
190 Cypress Ave, Brooklyn, NY 11237, United States

Sicily's Best is a renowned pizza restaurant located in Brooklyn, NY. They offer a variety of service options like kerbside pickup, delivery, and dine-in. Known for their fast service, Sicily's Best is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. They have a wheelchair-accessible entrance and accept various payments including credit cards and NFC mobile payments.

With a rating of 4.5 stars, Sicily's Best has received positive reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some key points from the reviews:

Pizza Park#15
What stands out
  • The pizza is very good and not greasy, loaded with toppings.

  • The staff is super friendly and welcoming, making the dining experience pleasant.

  • The store is very clean, with a unique setup of stainless steel tables and chairs.

Pizza Park

4.3387 reviews
1233 1st Ave. #6309, New York, NY 10065, United States

Pizza Park is a neighborhood pizzeria in New York that offers a variety of services and features to its customers. Customers can enjoy no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The restaurant is known for its fast service and popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. They offer comfort food, late-night food, quick bites, and vegetarian options. Their atmosphere is described as casual, making it perfect for groups and university students.

MLocal option
#16
What stands out
  • Great selection of pies with ample toppings

  • Good neighborhood spot for a slice

  • Efficient service and amazing food

  • Delicious pizza, quick, fresh, and hot

Margari Pizza

4.1157 reviews
1072 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States

Margari Pizza is a beloved pizza restaurant located in New York. They offer a variety of service options such as Delivery, No-contact delivery, Kerbside pickup, Outdoor seating, and Dine-in. Known for being popular for Lunch and Dinner, Margari Pizza caters to individuals looking for a quick and delicious bite.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

The comparison at a glance

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Joe's Pizza 4.58,508
#2Joe’s Pizza 4.64,354
#3Uncle Sam's Pizza 4.81,059
#4Song' E Napule 4.71,801
#5Sicily Osteria 4.71,505
#6Vito's Slices and Ices 4.71,170
#7Piccola Cucina Osteria Siciliana 4.61,903
#8John's Pizzeria of Times Square 4.37,017
#9Norma Hell's Kitchen 4.6667
#10Artichoke Basille's Pizza 4.32,936
#11Famous Famiglia Pizza 4.41,316
#12Siena Pizza 4.5637
#13Don Filippo 4.4716
#14Sicily's Best 4.5171
#15Pizza Park 4.3387
#16Margari Pizza 4.1157

Run a business?

Manage or add my business

Map of Sicilian Pizza in New York

Whether you're a local looking for your next slice of heaven or a visitor wanting to experience the iconic flavors of New York, this map of all the best Sicilian pizza spots in the city is a must-have guide for any pizza lover. Discover the top-rated pizzerias offering delicious thick-crust pies that will satisfy your tastebuds.

How to choose Sicilian Pizza in New York City

  1. Various toppings and flavor options.
  2. Quality of ingredients used.
  3. Delivery and takeout services available.
  4. Prices and portion sizes.
  5. Customer reviews and ratings.

Frequently asked questions

What makes Sicilian pizza in New York unique?

Sicilian pizza in New York is distinctively thick and doughy, with a focaccia-like crust that is crispy on the outside and soft on the inside. The pizza is typically rectangular in shape, with toppings spread evenly across the dough. The generous amount of cheese and sauce used gives Sicilian pizza in New York a rich and satisfying flavor. Unlike other styles of pizza, Sicilian pizza is baked in a pan rather than directly on the oven rack. This method results in a deep dish pizza with a hearty crust that can hold the weight of multiple toppings. The square slices are perfect for sharing with friends and family, making it a popular choice for group gatherings. Overall, the unique texture, flavor, and presentation of Sicilian pizza in New York set it apart from other pizza styles in the city, making it a must-try for pizza enthusiasts.

Where can I find the best Sicilian pizza in New York?

There are numerous pizza establishments in New York that serve delicious Sicilian pizza. Some popular spots include L&B Spumoni Gardens in Brooklyn, Prince Street Pizza in Manhattan, and Artichoke Basille’s Pizza with multiple locations across the city. Each of these pizzerias has its own unique take on Sicilian pizza, with different crust thickness, sauce variations, and topping combinations. Whether you prefer a classic cheese pie or a gourmet creation, you are sure to find a Sicilian pizza that tickles your taste buds in New York. For the best experience, consider exploring different neighborhoods and trying out various pizzerias to discover your favorite Sicilian pizza spot in New York.

Is Sicilian pizza in New York different from Sicilian pizza in Italy?

While both Sicilian pizza in New York and Sicilian pizza in Italy share some similarities, there are key differences between the two styles. New York Sicilian pizza is typically thicker and doughier, with a greater emphasis on toppings and cheese. In contrast, traditional Sicilian pizza in Italy is often thinner and crisper, with a focus on quality ingredients such as fresh tomatoes, olive oil, and locally sourced cheeses. The flavors are simpler and more rustic, reflecting the culinary heritage of the region. Ultimately, both styles of Sicilian pizza have their unique appeal, and it's worth trying both versions to appreciate the diversity of this beloved dish.

What are some popular toppings for Sicilian pizza in New York?

Sicilian pizza in New York offers a wide range of topping options to suit every palate. Some popular choices include: These classic toppings can be combined in various ways to create unique and delicious flavor combinations. Whether you prefer a simple cheese pie or a loaded meat lover's Sicilian pizza, there is a topping combination for everyone in New York. Many pizzerias also offer specialty toppings such as artichokes, spinach, prosciutto, and ricotta cheese, allowing you to customize your Sicilian pizza to your liking. Pepperoni. Sausage. Mushrooms. Peppers. Onions. Olives. Meatballs.

Related guides