The 4 Best Key Lime Pie in New York

When it comes to indulging in a slice of key lime pie in the Big Apple, there are plenty of delicious options to choose from. Whether you're a New Yorker looking to satisfy your sweet tooth or a visitor wanting to taste a traditional NYC dessert, finding the perfect slice of Key Lime Pie in New York is a must.

From classic bakeries to trendy dessert spots, the city offers a diverse range of eateries serving up this tangy and sweet treat. To help you navigate the bustling culinary scene, we have compiled a list of the top spots in the city to enjoy a slice of Key Lime Pie.

• Authentic key lime flavor
• Crumbly graham cracker crust
• Fresh whipped cream toppings
• Cozy ambiance

Get ready to embark on a flavorful journey through the city as you discover the very best places to enjoy a delicious slice of Key Lime Pie in New York.

The 4 Best Key Lime Pie in New York

+1 212-736-4780

www.littlepiecompany.com

• Monday: 8 AM–8 PM
• Tuesday: 8 AM–8 PM
• Wednesday: 8 AM–8 PM
• Thursday: 8 AM–8 PM
• Friday: 8 AM–8 PM
• Saturday: 10 AM–8 PM
• Sunday: 10 AM–6 PM

1. Little Pie Company

4.6/5 (More than 1136 reviews)

424 W 43rd St, New York, NY 10036, United States

Pie shop

Information and Reviews

Little Pie Company is a beloved pie shop located in New York, offering a variety of delicious pies and desserts. With a rating of 4.6 stars from 1136 reviews, customers have consistently praised the quality and flavors of the pies.

• Desserts are good but a bit pricey. Best macchiato.
• Excellent service with a cozy atmosphere.
• Delicious drinks that exceed expectations.
• Fast service with friendly staff.

Customers have highlighted pies like the old fashioned apple, sour cream apple walnut, and strawberry rhubarb for their exceptional taste and quality. The owner's presence adds a personal touch, creating a warm and welcoming environment for visitors. Whether you're looking for a quick visit or a cozy spot to enjoy great food, Little Pie Company is the perfect place to satisfy your sweet tooth.

+1 718-858-5333

keylime.com

• Monday: 12–6 PM
• Tuesday: 12–6 PM
• Wednesday: 12–6 PM
• Thursday: 12–6 PM
• Friday: 12–7 PM
• Saturday: 11 AM–7 PM
• Sunday: 11 AM–7 PM

2. Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie

4.7/5 (More than 645 reviews)

185 Van Dyke St, Brooklyn, NY 11231, United States

Pie shop

Information and Reviews

Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pie is a renowned pie shop located in Brooklyn, NY. Known for its Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, Takeaway, and Same-day delivery services, this establishment ensures that customers can enjoy their delicious Key Lime Pies at their convenience. The wheelchair-accessible car park and entrance make it easily accessible to all. Customers rave about the taste and quality of their Key Lime Pies, with a high rating of 4.7.

Some key points from customer reviews:

• Top 3 Key Lime Pie in New York with an excellent pie crust and smooth Key Lime flavor.
• Authentic Key Lime Pie that rivals those from Key Largo, Florida.
• Great views of the Statue of Liberty while enjoying delicious flavors of Key Lime Pie.
• Highly recommended for those looking to experience top-notch Key Lime Pies in a picturesque setting.

+1 646-494-3630

www.peteespie.com

• Monday: 11 AM–11 PM
• Tuesday: 11 AM–11 PM
• Wednesday: 11 AM–11 PM
• Thursday: 11 AM–11 PM
• Friday: 11 AM–11 PM
• Saturday: 11 AM–11 PM
• Sunday: 11 AM–11 PM

3. Petee's Pie Company

4.6/5 (More than 907 reviews)

61 Delancey St, New York, NY 10002, United States

Pie shop

Information and Reviews

Petee's Pie Company is a renowned pie shop located in New York. They offer a variety of delicious pies for customers to enjoy. The business provides various service options such as delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, and takeaway. Customers have praised the impeccable taste of the pies and the friendly service they received.

• Customers love the Keylime pie for its perfect balance of sweet and tart flavors.
• The Coconut and Blueberry Crumble pie received rave reviews for its delicious crust-to-filling ratio.
• The Brown Butter Honey Pecan pie left customers satisfied with its appetizing smell and perfect level of sweetness.

With a stellar rating of 4.6 and 907 reviews, Petee's Pie Company continues to impress customers with their delectable pies and excellent service. Visit their website to explore their menu and place an order!

Phone not available

caitskeylime.com

Hours not available

4. Cait's Key Lime

4.9/5 (More than 45 reviews)

Willoughby Street & Jay Street, Brooklyn, NY 11201, United States

Bakery

Information and Reviews

Cait's Key Lime is a charming Bakery located in Brooklyn, NY. They offer Delivery and Takeaway service options, perfect for anyone looking for a quick and delicious treat. Customers rave about their Key Lime Pie, describing it as the best they have ever had. Some key points from their reviews include:

• The ratio of cream to the rest of the pie is perfect, and the flavor is unmatched.
• The crust is the perfect texture, and the filling is a balance of sweet and tart.
• The ingredients are fresh and carefully sourced, making every bite a delight.
• Customers appreciate the responsiveness and professionalism of the owner, Cait.

If you're in the mood for a delectable dessert that will leave you wanting more, be sure to check out Cait's Key Lime.

Map of Key Lime Pie in New York

For those dessert lovers craving a taste of the Florida Keys without leaving New York City, look no further. Discover the best spots in the Big Apple to indulge in a delicious and authentic Key Lime Pie experience. From trendy bakeries to classic diners, this map will guide you to the perfect slice of paradise.

What makes key lime pie unique in New York?

Key lime pie in New York is known for its creamy texture and tangy flavor that comes from the use of Key limes, which are smaller and more aromatic than regular limes.

The pie is often made with a graham cracker crust and topped with whipped cream or meringue, adding a contrast of textures that New Yorkers love.

Many bakeries in New York put their own twist on the classic recipe, incorporating local ingredients or offering variations like key lime cheesecake or key lime cupcakes.

Where can I find the best key lime pie in New York?

Some popular spots for key lime pie in New York include Joe's Stone Crab in Manhattan, known for their authentic Florida-style pie, and Little Pie Company in Hell's Kitchen, which offers a decadent version of the dessert.

Other bakeries and restaurants worth checking out for key lime pie in New York include Steve's Authentic Key Lime Pies in Red Hook, Brooklyn, and Baked in Tribeca, which puts a creative twist on the traditional recipe.

Additionally, many diners and cafes across the city offer their own take on key lime pie, so be sure to explore different neighborhoods to find your favorite slice.

Is key lime pie a popular dessert in New York?

Key lime pie has gained popularity in New York in recent years, with many dessert lovers seeking out the tangy and refreshing treat as an alternative to richer desserts like cheesecake or chocolate cake.

The pie is often seen on dessert menus at upscale restaurants, diners, and bakeries across the city, with variations that cater to different tastes, from traditional to gourmet twists on the classic recipe.

Many New Yorkers consider key lime pie a must-try when visiting the city, with foodies and tourists alike seeking out the best slices in town to satisfy their sweet tooth.

Can I buy key lime pie to take home in New York?

Yes, many bakeries and specialty food stores in New York sell key lime pie for takeout or delivery, making it easy to enjoy the dessert in the comfort of your own home.

Some places even offer frozen key lime pies that you can bake at home, ensuring that you can enjoy a fresh and delicious slice anytime you crave it.

Be sure to check online for local bakeries or gourmet food shops that offer key lime pie delivery or pickup options to satisfy your dessert cravings.