The 16 Best Restaurants in Port Jefferson, New York

Joey Z's Restaurant is a beloved Mediterranean restaurant located in Port Jefferson, NY. Known for its extensive menu of Mediterranean and American classics, this restaurant delivers delicious food without any frills. The friendly staff and comfortable atmosphere make it a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

• Extensive menu offering Mediterranean and American classics
• Great service with friendly staff
• Comfortable atmosphere
• Popular with locals and tourists

Customers rave about the mouthwatering dishes, top-notch service, and memorable dining experience. One patron praised the flavorful linguine with pesto and chicken, mouthwatering margarita pizza, and delectable fried calamari mozzarella sticks. Another mentioned the exceptional care taken to meet their dietary needs and the delicious gluten-free/dairy-free options available. Reviewers also mention that the food portions are large and worth the price, making it one of the best restaurants in Port Jefferson.

The Fifth Season is an iconic American restaurant located in Port Jefferson, NY. Known for its outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, takeaway, and dine-in options, this restaurant offers a variety of services tailored to meet the needs of its customers.

One of the highlights of The Fifth Season is its cozy fireplace, great coffee, and delicious desserts that keep patrons coming back for more. Whether you're looking for a spot to enjoy lunch or a place for a special dinner, this restaurant caters to all occasions.

Customers rave about their experiences at The Fifth Season, pointing out the excellent food, drinks, and service. Some key points from customer reviews include:

• Varied menu options from salads to steak and desserts
• Impeccable service and memorable experiences
• Delicious dishes with excellent flavors and presentations
• Attentive and knowledgeable staff providing top-notch service

With a rating of 4.6 and 610 reviews, The Fifth Season continues to be a top choice for those seeking a memorable dining experience in Port Jefferson. Whether you're a local or just passing through, this restaurant is definitely worth a visit!

RUVO is a charming Restaurant located in Port Jefferson, NY. Known for its warm and inviting atmosphere, this spot is popular for both Lunch and Dinner. Customers rave about the delicious food offerings, such as the fried calamari and sea scallops over parmesan risotto.

• Ruvo offers a unique dining experience, perfect for sharing appetizers and enjoying cozy ambience.
• The staff, including servers like Dylan and Lori, go above and beyond to ensure a fantastic visit.
• Customers appreciate the diverse menu options, from comfort food to organic dishes, catering to all tastes.
• Overall, guests highly recommend Ruvo for a romantic date night or celebratory event, praising the quick and friendly service and delicious food choices.

With a rating of 4.5 stars and glowing reviews, Ruvo continues to impress diners with its exceptional service and delectable cuisine. Visit Ruvo's website for more information and to make reservations.

Ferryman's Grille is a charming restaurant located in Port Jefferson, NY. With a rating of 4.6 stars based on 411 reviews, it is clear that customers have had some great experiences here.

• The food was top-notch, with delicious dishes such as the kale pizza and incredible scallops.
• Customers enjoyed the beautiful views of the harbor and the great selection of specialty cocktails.
• Service was a highlight for many, with servers like Juliana and Vanessa providing a fun and friendly experience.

Whether you're looking for a relaxing dinner by the water, live music, or a spot to enjoy brunch, Ferryman's Grille offers a variety of service options such as outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in. Make sure to stop by and experience it for yourself!

Tara Inn is a well-loved bar located in Port Jefferson, NY, offering a variety of services and amenities for its customers. The establishment provides options for takeaway, dine-in, and alcohol services. Customers can enjoy a range of highlights, including bar games, fast service, and a great beer selection. The cozy and casual atmosphere makes it an ideal spot for groups and tourists alike.

• Customers praise the excellent food at Tara Inn, emphasizing the affordable prices and generous portions.
• Reviewers highlight the friendly and laid-back service, noting that the staff makes everyone feel welcome and comfortable.
• Many patrons mention the unpretentious and chill vibe of the bar, making it a favorite hangout spot for locals and visitors alike.

Pasta Pasta is a popular restaurant located in Port Jefferson, New York. They offer a variety of services, including outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, takeaway, and dine-in options. The atmosphere is described as casual, cozy, and romantic, making it suitable for various occasions. Customers can enjoy great coffee and great dessert while having a meal. The menu includes a wide range of options, such as beer, coffee, comfort food, healthy options, vegan options, and vegetarian options.

• Pasta Pasta is a favorite spot for many customers due to its incredible menu options and cozy atmosphere.
• Customers praise the attentive and friendly service provided by the staff.
• The food is described as delicious, with highlights including the chocolate bag, Cajun pasta, seafood pizza, and garlic bread.

Old Fields Restaurant Port Jefferson is a cozy New American restaurant that offers a variety of services and features to enhance the dining experience. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options, along with highlights such as fast service, a fireplace, great coffee, and great desserts. The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, making it a great choice for solo dining or group gatherings.

Customer reviews rave about the fantastic meals, friendly service, and cozy ambiance of the restaurant. Three key points from the reviews include:

• Start with a delicious pumpkin martini and enjoy perfectly cooked dishes like salmon or the vegetarian-friendly Mezzi Orecchiette pasta with lemon cream sauce.
• The dim lighting, fireplace, and fall cocktails create a warm and inviting atmosphere, perfect for a memorable dining experience.
• The attentive staff, efficient service, and creative menu offerings make Old Fields a standout dining destination in Port Jefferson.

Prohibition Port Jefferson is a charming American restaurant located in the heart of Port Jefferson, NY. The restaurant offers a variety of service options including outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. A key highlight of this establishment is its fast service and live music atmosphere.

Customers rave about the delicious food and friendly staff at Prohibition Port Jefferson. Here are some key points distilled from customer reviews:

• The drink selection is fantastic, especially the specialty cocktails
• Food is fresh and flavorful, perfect for a meal outside of the city
• The atmosphere is cozy and inviting with good music
• Service is attentive and the staff goes above and beyond to ensure a great experience

With a rating of 4.5 out of 5 from 415 reviews, this restaurant is a must-visit spot for those looking for a great dining experience in Port Jefferson. Whether you're in the mood for a casual meal or live music entertainment, Prohibition Port Jefferson has something for everyone.

Grumpy Jack's is a popular bar & grill in Port Jefferson known for its fast service and cosy atmosphere. The establishment offers a variety of dining options such as lunch and dinner, making it a great spot for both solo dining and group gatherings. Customers have highlighted a few key points in their reviews:

• Quick service even on busy nights
• Delicious food with generous portions
• Family-friendly environment
• Good for casual dining experiences

Whether you're looking for a place to grab a quick bite or enjoy a leisurely meal with friends and family, Grumpy Jack's is a reliable choice that won't disappoint.

Billie's 1890 Saloon is a popular bar & grill located in Port Jefferson, NY. The establishment offers a variety of services and features that cater to different preferences. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The bar is known for its fast service and sports atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

With a rating of 4.5 stars based on 288 reviews, Billie's 1890 Saloon has received positive feedback from its customers. Here are some key points summarized from the reviews:

• Impromptu dinner experience with delicious appetizers like big pretzel, honey sriracha brussel sprouts, and chicken wings.
• Impressed by the burger and recommends it for anyone in the area.
• Great service, nice burger, and cold beer served with charisma and local knowledge.
• Beautiful ambiance but some food items lacked flavor and satisfaction.

Whether you're looking for a casual hangout, a cozy atmosphere, or historic charm, Billie's 1890 Saloon promises a pleasant dining experience for everyone. Make sure to check out this local gem and enjoy their array of offerings, including alcohol, beer, cocktails, coffee, and more!

PJ Lobster House is a renowned seafood restaurant in Port Jefferson, NY, known for its wide array of service options including outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, delivery, and more. Customers have praised the fast service and great dessert highlights. The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, catering to solo diners as well.

• One customer had a disappointing experience, citing issues with the quality of seafood and slow service.
• Another visitor had an amazing time, appreciating the attentive servers and perfectly cooked dishes like calamari and salmon.
• A returning customer loved the shrimp scampi and recommended the restaurant despite its slightly higher prices.
• A group celebrating a birthday enjoyed the delicious appetizers, generous main courses, and reasonable prices for a seafood restaurant.

Nantuckets is a charming American restaurant located in Port Jefferson, NY. Offering a delightful nautical ambiance and strategically positioned by the harbor, it is a perfect spot for various dining occasions. The restaurant boasts a range of service options such as outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in.

Customer reviews highlight the exceptional dining experience at Nantuckets:

• Delicious food with generous portions and excellent presentation
• Warm and inviting atmosphere with friendly and accommodating staff
• Beautiful waterfront location perfect for special celebrations

Gourmet Burger Bistro is a top-notch Hamburger restaurant located in Port Jefferson, NY. The restaurant offers a variety of services to cater to their customers' needs, including Outdoor seating, Kerbside pickup, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in options. The establishment is known for its fast service and great dessert selection.

Customers have praised the restaurant for several key points:

• Fresh and delicious food
• Great appetizers with dipping sauce
• Varied selection of burgers to try
• Excellent sweet potato fries and house beers

One customer raved about the delicious blue cheese burgers and the scrumptious sweet potato fries. Another mentioned enjoying their cheeseburger on a salad and how amazing the French fries were. Although some reviewers mentioned minor issues with their meals, the overall consensus is positive regarding the food quality and service at Gourmet Burger Bistro.

The Steam Room is a popular seafood restaurant located in Port Jefferson, NY. With a rating of 4.0 and a total of 1196 reviews, this establishment offers a variety of service options such as outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers have praised the fast service and highlighted the menu items like the lobster roll and fish platter as must-tries.

• Customers enjoy the delicious seafood pot and excellent fish platter with market-fresh prices.
• Some patrons have noted changes in the restaurant's setup with mixed feelings.
• Specials like the crab leg offer at great prices have been well-received.
• One review mentions the polite staff and fresh, delicious food served in minutes.

Barito Tacos & Cocktails is a Mexican restaurant located in Port Jefferson, NY. They offer a variety of service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers have highlighted the fast service and live music as some of the restaurant's highlights. It is popular for both lunch and dinner, as well as solo dining. The restaurant provides wheelchair-accessible seating and toilets for accessibility.

Here are some summarized customer reviews:

• Great place for drinks and appetizers! Loved the nachos! Our waitress was amazing! Very friendly and very efficient! Decor is very inviting. Place was packed, very hard to have a conversation but so much fun! (5 stars)
• Delicious Mexican food with a cool vibe and design. Shrimp bowl, fritter fries, and crispy cauliflower were amazing. Friendly and helpful service. (5 stars)
• Half off Taco Tuesdays, good tacos, blending flavors, wish portion sizes were larger. Great ambiance with fast service. (4 stars)
• Incredible Mexican fusion cuisine! Highly recommend the big mac tacos, dessert empanadas, cocktails, and more! Awesome gem with great ambiance. (5 stars)

Customers have praised the large food portions, delicious flavors, and great customer service at Barito Tacos & Cocktails. Visit their website for more information on their menu and offerings.

Port Bistro and Pub is a popular Gastropub located in Port Jefferson, NY. They offer a variety of services and features, including Outdoor seating, Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. The business is known for its Fast service and Live music performances. Customers have praised the food and atmosphere, leaving positive reviews. Some key points from the reviews include:

• Delicious IPA and good pub food
• Amazing staff, accommodating for private events
• Great food during special deals like Restaurant Week
• Best burgers ever, exceptional service, and fair prices

Visit their website or call +1 631-828-2550 to experience their offerings and lively atmosphere.