The 16 Best Restaurants in Montauk, New York

Harvest on Fort Pond is a popular restaurant situated in Montauk, NY. This establishment offers a range of service options including outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers also enjoy the great beer selection, cocktails, and wine list available. Known for being popular for dinner and solo dining, Harvest on Fort Pond ensures accessibility with wheelchair-accessible amenities.

With a wide variety of options like alcohol, coffee, comfort food, vegetarian options, and more, this restaurant caters to diverse tastes. Patrons can enjoy a casual, cosy, romantic, or trendy atmosphere with a family-friendly crowd. Reservations are highly recommended due to the popularity of this establishment.

Customer reviews rave about the family-size portions, delicious food, great views, and welcoming staff. The experience is described as superb with generous portions and great flavors. Here are some key points from recent reviews:

• Family-size portions
• Great service and food recommendations
• Delicious food with generous portions
• Beautiful atmosphere and friendly staff

The Montauket is a charming restaurant located in Montauk, NY, known for its breathtaking views and delightful atmosphere. Customers can enjoy a range of services and features, including Outdoor seating, Takeaway, Dine-in, and more. The establishment offers a variety of highlights such as Fast service, Great beer selection, and Live music to enhance the dining experience.

Customer reviews rave about the fantastic vibe and spectacular sunsets that can be witnessed at The Montauket. Some customers praise the great cocktails and the friendly staff, while others appreciate the family-friendly atmosphere and reasonable pricing. Overall, the majority of reviews highlight the amazing views and the enjoyable experience at this lovely establishment.

• Great vibe. Live music and the Sunset is beyond amazing. Fantastic all around.
• Nice view, food was decent. Unfortunately we waited more than an hour for our food. Not really worth it but the bar part is cool!
• What a great view! It is unfortunate that they don't serve food til May, but I enjoyed being here.
• IT IS THE BEST PLACE TO ENJOY A DRINK WHILE YOU OBSERVE THE SPECTACULAR SUNSETS THAT MONTAUK OFFERS YOU

668 The Gig Shack is a vibrant New American restaurant in Montauk, NY that offers a variety of dining experiences. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The restaurant is known for its fast service and live music, creating a lively atmosphere for all visitors.

Here are a few key points from customer reviews:

• Delicious mussels and great bar seating with fun music.
• Buttery lobster sliders, tasty burgers, and efficient staff.
• Warm atmosphere and good food, even for non-seafood fans.
• Highly recommend for succulent ribs, delicious sauces, and cool surfer decor.

Whether you're looking for a quick bite, a leisurely meal, or a lively evening with live music, 668 The Gig Shack has something for everyone. Give them a visit to enjoy a fusion of flavors and a memorable dining experience.

Gosman's Restaurant is a well-known seafood restaurant located in Montauk, NY. They offer a range of services and features like outdoor seating, takeaway, dine-in, and have a wheelchair-accessible entrance for customer convenience. In terms of offerings, this restaurant provides alcohol, beer, cocktails, coffee, comfort food, small plates, spirits, and wine. Their dining options include brunch, lunch, dinner, and dessert, with seating available.

Customer reviews highlight a few key points:

• Great food, including salmon, burgers, and shrimp basket, but one incident of food poisoning reported
• Disappointing experience due to seating flexibility issues
• Delicious food, nice service, and beautiful outdoor seating area
• Amazing service and food, stunning views, but long wait times and high prices

Inlet Seafood Restaurant is a renowned seafood restaurant located in Montauk, NY. Their services include outdoor seating, takeaway, dine-in, and more. Customers can enjoy various amenities like a fireplace, great dessert, and even live music while dining. The restaurant is known for being popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

The atmosphere at Inlet Seafood Restaurant is described as casual, cosy, romantic, and trendy. The establishment is also family-friendly and LGBTQ+ friendly, making it a welcoming place for all.

Here are some summarized customer reviews:

• Great location with delicious seafood and lovely complex flavors.
• Good food and atmosphere, but slow service due to a lack of staff.
• Amazing food and atmosphere for a special celebration, with exceptional flavors and beautiful plating.
• Excellent food, fantastic seafood options, and a wonderful dining experience with great service.

The Point Bar & Grill is a popular establishment located in Montauk, NY, offering a variety of services and features. With options for Takeaway, Dine-in, and popular for both Lunch and Dinner, this bar & grill provides a welcoming atmosphere for all. Customers can enjoy Fast service, Live music, Live performances, and sports while indulging in a menu that includes comfort food, small plates, and a wide selection of beverages. The bar on-site ensures a good time for all patrons looking to unwind in a casual and trendy environment.

Here are the summarized reviews from customers:

• The beer is good. The food is well prepared and quite tasty. Very tasty dessert.
• Got the Point burger and asked for medium rare. It was cooked perfect and tasted decent as well.
• Food was decent, but needed more seasoning. Great view by the ocean.
• Starting off the Montauk season with good eats, friendly staff, and a relaxed vibe. Great burgers and fair prices.

Alimentari Beach Montauk is a renowned Italian restaurant located in Montauk, NY. The establishment offers a variety of services, including outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, takeaway, and dine-in options. Customers can enjoy a quick bite or indulge in a full meal, with offerings ranging from alcohol and cocktails to comfort food and wine.

This cozy restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, making it a great spot for solo diners or groups. Customer reviews rave about the impeccable service and delicious food. In summary, customers have highlighted the following key points in their reviews:

• Appetizers were spot on, entrees were delicious, and desserts were fantastic.
• Great gluten-free options with delicious cauliflower crust pizza.
• Affordable prices, friendly service, and fresh, amazing pizza.
• Must-try AB Italian sandwich made with homemade bread.

Whether you're looking for a casual meal with family or a cozy dinner with friends, Alimentari Beach Montauk promises a delightful dining experience. Make sure to visit this gem for a taste of authentic Italian cuisine!

Muse @ The End is a beloved New American restaurant located in Montauk, NY. With a rating of 4.3, it is known for its variety of services and features catering to different tastes and preferences.

Customers have left positive reviews highlighting the following key points:

• Pleasantly surprised by the well-prepared salads and tasty burgers
• Delicious food, but wished the staff had helped with boxing leftovers
• Generous portions and rich flavors in dishes like shrimp scampi

The restaurant offers a range of service options such as outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in. It is popular for lunch and dinner, with a cozy and casual atmosphere. Customers can enjoy amenities like a bar on-site and gender-neutral toilets.

With a focus on quality food and welcoming ambiance, Muse @ The End continues to be a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike in Montauk.

The Crow's Nest is a charming restaurant located in Montauk, NY, known for its inviting atmosphere and delicious dishes. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating and a cozy fireplace while savoring their meal. The restaurant offers a wide range of options, including Alcohol, Cocktails, Organic dishes, Vegetarian options, and Wine.

• The Crow’s Nest is great! Customers appreciated the late-night drinks and post-dinner atmosphere, with multiple bars and great music vibes.
• Families enjoyed the family-friendly environment and large food portions, recommending sharing to avoid overordering.
• A satisfied customer praised the excellent service, packed yet steady pace, and the amazing chef, recommending the place for all clients and friends.

South Edison is a well-established seafood restaurant located in Montauk, NY. They offer a variety of dining options such as dinner and dessert, and provide amenities like a bar on site and gender-neutral toilets. The atmosphere at South Edison is described as casual and cozy, making it a perfect spot for a relaxing meal.

Customers have left rave reviews about their experiences at South Edison. Some key points from their reviews include:

• Amazing food and desserts, especially the smash burgers and Buffalo Chicken Bites
• Great cocktails and attentive service
• Mind-blowing dishes with bold flavors and textures

With a rating of 4.3 and over 200 reviews, South Edison continues to impress locals and tourists alike. Don't miss out on the culinary delights this restaurant has to offer!

Scarpetta Beach offers a delightful dining experience with a stunning oceanfront view. The restaurant provides a range of service options, including outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy great cocktails, coffee, dessert, and an impressive wine list. The menu caters to various appetites with offerings like healthy options, small plates, and vegetarian dishes.

Customers have had rave reviews about Scarpetta Beach, with some key points highlighted:

• Fantastic menu with compelling fare
• Excellent dishes overshadowing the beautiful oceanfront setting
• Beautiful ambience, but food quality fell short for some
• Impeccable service and top-notch dining experience

The restaurant caters to different occasions, offering options for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. Scarpetta Beach is known for its accessibility, amenities, and overall atmospheric setting. With positive reviews and a 4.2 rating, customers are drawn to the memorable experience offered by this exquisite dining establishment.

Sel Rrose Montauk is a charming restaurant located in Montauk, NY. With a rating of 4.2 stars from 190 reviews, it's no surprise that customers have amazing things to say about this establishment.

• Consistently delicious food with standout items like truffle fries, salmon, oysters Rockefeller, and short rib.
• Excellent cocktails and fresh oysters, with must-try dishes like truffle risotto and Lavender Chocolate Pots to Crème.
• Exceptional food quality, superb wine selection, and unique ambiance with beautiful decor.
• Gorgeous atmosphere with unique decor, fantastic drinks menu, perfect food, and friendly, attentive staff.

Customers rave about the gorgeous decor, exceptional service, and delicious food at Sel Rrose Montauk. From the monochrome murals to the cozy ambiance, every detail adds to the perfect dining experience. Whether you're looking for a place to enjoy cocktails, fresh seafood, or a cozy dinner, this restaurant has it all. Visit Sel Rrose Montauk for a delightful culinary experience that will leave you coming back for more.

Navy Beach Restaurant is a hidden gem nestled in Montauk, offering top-notch seafood cuisine and a charming atmosphere. With a solid 3.9-star rating, customers have praised this spot for various reasons:

• Perfect venue for a micro wedding
• Ideal setting for a celebration
• Great local restaurant with delicious food

The restaurant provides service options such as outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in. You can also enjoy live music and sport activities while savoring your meal. The variety of options include alcohol, cocktails, coffee, and even organic dishes. The atmosphere is described as casual, cosy, romantic, and trendy, catering to a diverse crowd. Don't miss out on a chance to dine at Navy Beach Restaurant for a memorable experience!

Tauk at Trail's End is an American restaurant located in Montauk, NY, known for its array of services and features. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner and is ideal for solo dining. Some of the highlights include fast service, great dessert, live music, and sport.

The bustling atmosphere at Tauk at Trail's End is reflected in the positive customer reviews. Reviewers have highlighted the generous portions, friendly service, and excellent chowder. The outstanding food quality and attentive staff make it a favorite spot for many visitors. Some key points from customer reviews include:

• We stopped in for a preseason price fixe dinner. The food was delicious and promptly presented.
• Great place to stop for a quick bite with enhanced safety measures taken during the pandemic. The lobster roll was tasty and worth the price.
• Great bar with amazing food options like the French Dip and chicken sandwich.
• Phenomenal food with a focus on safety during the pandemic, including spaced-out seating and mandatory masks.

Sammys is a renowned seafood restaurant located in Montauk, NY. With a rating of 4.0 stars, it has garnered positive reviews from numerous customers. Some key points from their reviews include:

• Lovely place with a supreme Lobster sandwich and a lovely setting by the bay.
• Great fish and chips, top-notch drinks, and an exceptional dining experience.
• Amazing place to get reasonably priced delicious takeout breakfast or lunch.
• Delicious Oktoberfest dinner with exceptional Sauerbraten and Wienerschnitzel.

Experience the outstanding service options like outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in. Indulge in popular offerings like alcohol, cocktails, and comfort food. Don't miss out on their fast service and cozy atmosphere. Visit Sammys for a memorable dining experience in Montauk!

Duryea's Montauk is a renowned seafood restaurant located in Montauk, NY. The establishment offers a variety of services including kerbside pickup, takeaway, and dine-in options. They are popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. The restaurant is wheelchair-accessible and provides amenities such as toilets and Wi-Fi.

Customer reviews highlight the following key points:

• Delicious and flavorful lobster roll
• Great atmosphere with pleasant views
• Generous food servings and excellent wines
• Occasional long wait times but worth it