Menu

New York City

The 16 Best Pizza in New York Midtown

When it comes to iconic food in New York, pizza is always at the top of the list. And in the bustling area of Midtown, there is no shortage of pizzerias to choose from. Whether you're a local looking for your go-to spot or a visitor wanting to try the best pizza in the area, Midtown has something for everyone.

From classic New York style slices to gourmet pies with unique toppings, Midtown pizza spots offer a wide range of options to satisfy any craving. With so many choices, it can be overwhelming to decide where to get your next slice. That's why we've curated a list of the 16 best pizza places in New York Midtown to help you narrow down your options and find the perfect spot for your next pizza craving.

Explore this list to discover the top pizza spots in Midtown and find your new favorite pizzeria in the heart of New York City.

How this guide is ordered

Chosen by our New York editors from places across the five boroughs, giving weight to a long track record with locals, current opening details and how well each one delivers on what it promises. Lists are revisited often; tell us when a spot closes or moves.

Featured businesses may pay for a more visible position within the guide.

Top 3Full listMapHow to choose

Quick view

Featured options

Select an option to see its summary.

#1
Joe's Pizza Broadway
4.518,277 reviews
#2
Carnegie Pizza
4.71,118 reviews
#3
John's Pizzeria of Times Square
4.37,017 reviews

Full list

Compare 16 local options

Joe's Pizza Broadway#1
What stands out

  • Quick, cheap, and delicious pizza with a charming vibe.

  • Great pizza experience with efficient service and delicious slices.

  • Authentic New York style pizza with fast service and friendly staff.

  • Definitely worth the wait for crispy, flavorful slices and a must-try experience.

Joe's Pizza Broadway

4.518,277 reviews
1435 Broadway, New York, NY 10018, United States

Joe's Pizza Broadway is a well-known pizza restaurant located in the heart of New York City, offering a variety of services to satisfy their customers' needs. This establishment is popular for its fast service and provides outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options.

Customers have highlighted some key points in their reviews:

Visitors praise the thin, crispy crust topped with a generous amount of cheese and perfectly balanced tomato sauce. Whether you're a local or a tourist, Joe's Pizza Broadway promises an authentic New York pizza experience that will leave you satisfied and coming back for more.

Carnegie Pizza#2
What stands out

  • Great spot near Times Square with fantastic stone-baked, thin-crust pizzas

  • Delicious garlic knots and quick service from friendly staff

  • Fresh and flavorful slices, worth every penny

  • Perfect place for NY-style sliced pizza with a huge variety of classic flavors

Carnegie Pizza

4.71,118 reviews
200 W 41st St, New York, NY 10036, United States

Carnegie Pizza is a bustling pizza restaurant located in the heart of New York City. The eatery offers a range of service options including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and dine-in for those who wish to enjoy their meal on-site. They are well-known for their fast service and are popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

Customer reviews rave about the delicious pizza offered at Carnegie Pizza, with some key points being:

Visitors have also praised the atmosphere of Carnegie Pizza, describing it as casual and trendy, perfect for both tourists and university students. Whether you're looking for a quick bite, a relaxing meal, or some delicious comfort food, Carnegie Pizza is a must-visit when in the area.

John's Pizzeria of Times Square#3
What stands out

  • Zero wait time after a matinee show

  • Enormous pizzas ideal for sharing

  • Great service and tasty food

  • Communal and family-friendly atmosphere

John's Pizzeria of Times Square

4.37,017 reviews
260 W 44th St, New York, NY 10036, United States

John's Pizzeria of Times Square is a renowned pizza restaurant located in the heart of New York City. With a rating of 4.3 stars, this establishment offers a range of services to satisfy every customer's needs.

Customers have praised the fast service provided by the friendly staff at John's Pizzeria of Times Square. The restaurant is popular for both lunch and dinner, making it a versatile choice for any time of day. Additionally, it is ideal for solo dining, ensuring a comfortable and enjoyable experience for those dining alone.

Whether you're a local or a tourist, John's Pizzeria of Times Square is a must-visit spot for delicious pizza and a unique dining experience in the bustling city.

$1.50 Fresh Pizza#4
What stands out

  • Unbeatable value for tasty pizza slices.

  • Convenient location near Grand Central with fresh pies.

  • Great option for budget-friendly and quick bites.

  • Excellent quality and generous portions, especially for the price.

$1.50 Fresh Pizza

4.52,087 reviews
151 E 43rd St, New York, NY 10017, United States

$1.50 Fresh Pizza is a beloved pizza restaurant in the heart of New York City, offering delicious slices at unbeatable prices. The establishment provides various service options such as no-contact delivery, takeaway, and dine-in for those looking to enjoy their meal in different ways.

Customers rave about the authentic taste of New York City pizza at $1.50 Fresh Pizza, emphasizing the simplicity and flavor of each slice. Here are some key points from satisfied customers:

Whether you're a local or a tourist, $1.50 Fresh Pizza promises a delightful and affordable culinary experience. Visit them today and treat yourself to a slice of pizza that won't disappoint!

Capizzi#5
What stands out

  • The pizza was beautifully crispy with a perfectly charred flavor from their wood-burning brick oven. However, some customers mentioned leaving a bit hungry after their meal.

  • Capizzi offers a cozy atmosphere capturing the essence of authentic Italian cuisine. Customers highlighted the outstanding Pizza Margherita.

  • Guests have appreciated the professional and attentive waitstaff, recommending making a reservation in advance.

  • Many have praised the delicious food and great service, making Capizzi a must-visit for those looking for a family-friendly dining experience with tasty pizza made in a brick oven. Customers also mentioned the flat rate on all bottles of wine.

Capizzi

4.51,926 reviews
547 9th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States

Capizzi is a beloved Pizza restaurant located in New York. They offer a variety of services such as Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. Known for their fast service, Capizzi is a popular spot for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining. Customers have left over 1926 reviews praising the restaurant with an impressive 4.5-star rating.

PizzArte#6
What stands out

  • Delicious gluten-free pizza that rivals traditional wheat options

  • Excellent service and cozy atmosphere

  • Impressive variety of gluten-free options and friendly staff

  • Highly recommended for those looking for a flavorful dining experience

PizzArte

4.51,615 reviews
69 W 55th St, New York, NY 10019, United States

PizzArte is a renowned Italian restaurant in New York that offers a range of services such as outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Known for their fast service and great dessert, PizzArte caters to those seeking a quick but delicious meal experience. Customers rave about the impeccable quality of their gluten-free pizza and entrees, showcasing their dedication to meeting dietary needs.

Some key points from customer reviews include:

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria#7
What stands out

  • Perfect crust, perfect flavor. Attentive and helpful staff. Would eat here again.

  • Crispy crust, perfectly balanced cheese and sauce. Highly recommended.

  • Delicious pizza that reminded us of Rome and Naples. Friendly staff, cozy atmosphere.

  • Fresh ingredients, thin crust, scrumptious sauce. Good service and reasonable prices.

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria

4.42,745 reviews
117 W 57th St, New York, NY 10001, United States

Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria is a renowned pizza restaurant located in New York. With a rating of 4.4 stars, this establishment offers a variety of services and features. Customers can enjoy the delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Known for its fast service, Angelo's is a popular choice for both lunch and dinner. The atmosphere is described as casual, cosy, and trendy, catering to various crowds including groups and tourists.

Here are some summarized reviews from satisfied customers:

$1.50 Fresh Pizza#8
What stands out

  • Pretty blessed spot for a dollar slice. Good people, good vibes, decent pizza.

  • An ok slice. Cheese and sauce were decent but the bread was spongy.

  • Listed as one of the best oven pizza outlets by a satisfied customer.

  • Buttery, slightly crispy, chewy pizza, considered one of the best slices ever had.

$1.50 Fresh Pizza

4.51,465 reviews
473 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10017, United States

$1.50 Fresh Pizza is a renowned Pizza restaurant located in the heart of New York City. The establishment offers a variety of services including No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in options, appealing to a wide range of preferences.

Known for being popular for Lunch and Dinner, this restaurant caters to solo diners and families alike. Their menu boasts Comfort food, Halal food, Late-night food, Quick bite, and Vegetarian options, ensuring there is something for everyone.

Customers have lauded $1.50 Fresh Pizza for its exceptional offerings. Reviews highlight the following key points:

With a rating of 4.5 stars and over 1465 reviews, $1.50 Fresh Pizza stands as a favorite among locals and tourists alike. Visit their website to explore their delicious offerings or stop by for a slice of piping hot pizza made fresh daily.

Uncle Paul's Pizza NY#9
What stands out

  • Great place for a slice of NY Style Pizza.

  • Favorite pizza in the city with great service and laid-back atmosphere.

  • Yummy thin crust flavorful pizza in a low-key atmosphere.

  • Awesome yummy pizza with friendly team and gluten-free options available.

Uncle Paul's Pizza NY

4.42,255 reviews
70 Vanderbilt Ave, New York, NY 10017, United States

Uncle Paul's Pizza NY is a well-loved Pizza restaurant located in New York, NY. The restaurant offers a variety of services and features to cater to its customers. Some of the service options available include No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. The establishment is known for its fast service and is popular for Lunch, Dinner, and Solo dining.

Customer reviews rave about Uncle Paul's Pizza NY. Here are some key points from the reviews:

These reviews reflect the overall positive experience customers have had at Uncle Paul's Pizza NY, making it a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in the area.

Little Italy Pizza#10
What stands out

  • I came here twice during my first NYC stay! It was my first true NY style pizza and oh my, I was very impressed. I loved it. Fantastic price, and a very quick, easy meal.

  • Right next to the Empire State Building and the service was quick and friendly! The pizza was amazing, perfect amount of toppings, and the crust was perfect.

  • Great NYC pizza! Good prices, friendly atmosphere, and clean dining area. A big thank you to the cashier that went above and beyond to help me when my nose started bleeding.

  • Some of the best pizza I’ve ever had. Great service, even when it’s busy, and even better prices!

Little Italy Pizza

4.23,756 reviews
2 E 33rd St, New York, NY 10016, United States

Little Italy Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located in New York, offering a variety of delicious pizzas. They provide delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Known for their fast service, this place is a favorite among locals and tourists alike.

Customers rave about the experience at Little Italy Pizza:

These reviews speak to the exceptional quality of food and service at Little Italy Pizza. If you're in the mood for authentic New York style pizza, this is the place to be!

2 Bros Pizza#11
What stands out

  • Delicious pizza with a variety of options

  • Affordable prices and quick service

  • Casual and trendy atmosphere

  • Great for families and kids

2 Bros Pizza

4.32,180 reviews
542 9th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States

2 Bros Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located in New York, offering a variety of service options like delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. They are known for their delicious and massive slices of pizza at affordable prices. Customers rave about the quality of the pizza, quick service, and overall dining experience.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.3 stars and over 2000 reviews, 2 Bros Pizza is a favorite spot for locals and tourists alike to enjoy a tasty slice of New York-style pizza. Customers highly recommend trying out their pizza and the popular Pepperoni Pizza.

Patsy's Pizzeria#12
What stands out

  • Came here based on Dave Portnoy's review. Pizza was delicious. Sauce. Cheese. Crispy crust. All delightful. Highly recommend.

  • Unreal! Our first pizza since landing from London, and the pizza was fabulous. Services were incredible, fast and lovely staff.

  • Food is OK. Not the same as Patsys Harlem but it's still alright. Nice place and team.

  • Worst restaurant experience ever! Rude server, wet straw, and terrible attitude. Not a pleasant visit.

Patsy's Pizzeria

4.31,301 reviews
801 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10017, United States

Patsy's Pizzeria is a renowned Pizza restaurant located in New York offering a variety of services. Customers can enjoy no-contact delivery, traditional delivery, takeaway, or dine-in options. The restaurant is known for its fast service and great dessert options, attracting visitors for lunch, dinner, or solo dining experiences. The establishment is accessible with wheelchair-accessible entrance and seating. Customers can enjoy a range of offerings including alcohol, beer, cocktails, coffee, comfort food, quick bites, spirits, and wine.

Angelo's Pizza#13
What stands out

  • Customers love the generously sized pizzas that are perfect for sharing.

  • The staff is incredibly friendly and provides excellent service.

  • The price for such delicious pizza is unbeatable.

  • The pizza is crispy and flavorful, making it one of the best in NYC.

Angelo's Pizza

4.22,100 reviews
1697 Broadway, New York, NY 10019, United States

Angelo's Pizza is a beloved pizza restaurant located in the heart of New York City. They offer a variety of service options, including Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. Customers rave about the fast service and the colossal pies that are perfect for sharing.

Fresh Pizza#14
What stands out

  • The pizza slices are relatively inexpensive and perfect for a quick bite.

  • Customers can get two slices and a soda for $5, which is a great deal.

  • For the price, Fresh Pizza is considered the best spot to get a slice or two, with affordable prices and great quality.

  • Hot slices, chewy crust, flavorful cheese and sauce, make Fresh Pizza the best meal deal around in midtown.

Fresh Pizza

4.1499 reviews
1032 6th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States

Fresh Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant in New York, offering a variety of service options including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy their delicious comfort food and late-night food in a casual atmosphere that is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining.

With a rating of 4.1 and 499 reviews, Fresh Pizza has garnered praise from its customers:

Visit Fresh Pizza today to enjoy a slice of delicious pizza at an affordable price!

New Times Square Pizza LLC#15
What stands out

  • Customers rave about the delicious and affordable pizzas.

  • The staff is friendly and accommodating, willing to customize orders.

  • The location is convenient, especially for those passing by Port Authority or exploring Times Square.

New Times Square Pizza LLC

4.1233 reviews
236 W 40th St, New York, NY 10018, United States

New Times Square Pizza LLC is a renowned pizza restaurant located in New York, offering a variety of services and features to its customers. From Kerbside pickup to No-contact delivery, this establishment ensures convenience and safety for all. Customers can enjoy their meals in a vibrant and casual atmosphere or opt for takeaway and delivery options.

With a rating of 4.1, based on 233 reviews, it is clear that New Times Square Pizza LLC has become a favorite among locals and visitors alike. Whether you're craving a classic margherita slice or a hearty BBQ chicken pizza, this establishment guarantees a satisfying experience for all pizza lovers.

MLocal option
#16
What stands out

  • I’ve been here a few times now and find it a good neighborhood spot for a slice. They always have a good selection of pies with ample toppings. Service is friendly and they have a good amount of seating. All in all, an easy lunch.

  • Restaurant was sold to new owners and I must say their food was amazing. I asked for Chicken Francaise and a plain slice to try and they were both amazing!! Def recommend!

  • Omg delish pizza, quick, fresh & hot. Had the chicken parm for the first time. Was impressed. Loved it. Place is cool and staff very friendly.

  • Would have loved to give this place 5 stars, but there is such a lack of consistency and quality when it comes to their food. Unfortunately, I just can’t 🙁

Margari Pizza

4.1157 reviews
1072 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10022, United States

Margari Pizza is a renowned pizza restaurant in New York offering a variety of options for its customers. With features like Outdoor seating, No-contact delivery, and Dine-in, they cater to all preferences. They are particularly popular for Lunch and Dinner, attracting both locals and tourists alike.

Customers have praised Margari Pizza for its delicious slices and friendly service. Some key points from the reviews include:

With a solid rating of 4.1, Margari Pizza continues to be a favorite spot for pizza lovers in the city.

Summary

The comparison at a glance

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Joe's Pizza Broadway 4.518,277
#2Carnegie Pizza 4.71,118
#3John's Pizzeria of Times Square 4.37,017
#4$1.50 Fresh Pizza 4.52,087
#5Capizzi 4.51,926
#6PizzArte 4.51,615
#7Angelo's Coal Oven Pizzeria 4.42,745
#8$1.50 Fresh Pizza 4.51,465
#9Uncle Paul's Pizza NY 4.42,255
#10Little Italy Pizza 4.23,756
#112 Bros Pizza 4.32,180
#12Patsy's Pizzeria 4.31,301
#13Angelo's Pizza 4.22,100
#14Fresh Pizza 4.1499
#15New Times Square Pizza LLC 4.1233
#16Margari Pizza 4.1157

For businesses

Run a business?

Manage or add my business

Map and areas

Map of Pizza in New York Midtown

New York City's Midtown is a pizza lover's paradise, with an abundance of pizzerias offering a wide variety of styles and flavors. From classic New York slices to gourmet toppings, there's something for every palate in this bustling neighborhood. Check out the map below to discover some of the best pizza spots in Midtown.

How to choose Pizza in New York City

  1. Location.
  2. Price.
  3. Specialty pizzas.
  4. Ratings and reviews.

Frequently asked questions

Where can I find the best pizza in Midtown?

If you're looking for authentic New York-style pizza in Midtown, there are several iconic pizza joints to check out. One popular spot is Joe's Pizza on West 44th Street, known for its delicious thin crust pies. Another favorite is Don Antonio by Starita on West 50th Street, which offers a variety of traditional and gourmet toppings. If you prefer a slice on the go, make sure to stop by 2 Bros Pizza on West 38th Street for their no-frills, budget-friendly option. For a more upscale experience, try Zero Otto Nove on West 21st Street, known for their Neapolitan-style pizzas.

What are the typical pizza toppings available in Midtown?

In Midtown, you can find a wide variety of pizza toppings to suit all tastes. Some of the most popular options include pepperoni, mushrooms, onions, peppers, sausage, and olives. Many pizzerias also offer specialty toppings like artichokes, prosciutto, arugula, and truffle oil for those looking to try something new. For a taste of classic New York flavor, don't forget to try a plain cheese pizza, which highlights the delicious combination of mozzarella and tomato sauce.

Are there any gluten-free pizza options in Midtown?

For those with gluten sensitivities or dietary preferences, there are several pizzerias in Midtown that offer gluten-free pizza options. Sottocasa Pizzeria on West 51st Street and Delizia 92 on 59th Street are known for their delicious gluten-free crusts and fresh toppings. Be sure to check with the pizzeria in advance to ensure they can accommodate your dietary needs and to inquire about their specific gluten-free options.

Can I order pizza for delivery in Midtown?

Yes, many pizzerias in Midtown offer delivery services for those looking to enjoy pizza in the comfort of their own home or office. You can order from popular chains like Domino's, Papa John's, and Pizza Hut, or opt for local favorites that offer online ordering through platforms like Grubhub, Seamless, and Uber Eats. Keep in mind that delivery times may vary depending on the pizzeria's location and current demand, so it's always a good idea to place your order ahead of time.

Related guides

The 16 Best New York Pizza Near MeThe 16 Best Crepes in New York CityThe 16 Best Steakhouse in Syracuse, New York