The 16 Best Pizza in Buffalo, New York

Extra Extra Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located in Buffalo, NY. They offer a variety of service options including takeaway, dine-in, and delivery. Their fast service and delicious Sicilian Pizza have earned them a stellar rating of 4.9 based on 198 reviews.

Here are some highlights from customer reviews:

• Sicilian Pizza is the best they've ever had
• Atmosphere is welcoming and cool
• Tipless restaurant is a respectful and unique concept
• Delicious thin crust pizza with flexible yet crunchy crust

Customers appreciate the high quality of food, the welcoming atmosphere, and the unique concept of a tipless establishment. If you're in Buffalo, don't miss out on the exceptional experience at Extra Extra Pizza!

Imperial Pizza - Abbott Road is a beloved pizza restaurant in Buffalo, NY, known for its delicious food and excellent service. Some of the service options available include outdoor seating, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Patrons can enjoy the highlights of fast service and a sports atmosphere while dining. Popular for both lunch and dinner, Imperial Pizza is a go-to spot for solo dining as well.

Customers have shared their experiences, with reviews praising the food quality and overall dining experience. Here are some key points from their feedback:

• The cheeseburger was delightful with ample portions of French fries, and the delivery service was friendly.
• While the restaurant offers an extensive menu with free parking, the flavors of some dishes fell short of expectations, and the food temperature was inconsistent.
• Visitors highly recommend trying out the lunch specials, especially the BBQ garlic parmesan wings, which are described as the best ever.
• Despite the tasty pizza, one reviewer expressed concerns about observed health and hygiene practices, impacting the overall experience.

Whether you're a local or a tourist, Imperial Pizza - Abbott Road is a must-visit establishment for a satisfying meal experience.

Joe's New York Style Pizza is a beloved pizza restaurant in Buffalo, NY, known for its delicious pies and friendly service. Customers rave about the quality of the food and the welcoming atmosphere of the restaurant.

• Customers love the friendly staff and delicious pizzas.
• The restaurant offers a variety of service options, including kerbside pickup and delivery.
• Many appreciate the fast service and the variety of menu options available.

Whether you're looking for a quick bite, a casual lunch, or a trendy dinner spot, Joe's New York Style Pizza has something for everyone. From their famous NY-style pizzas to their comforting pasta dishes, this restaurant is a must-visit for pizza lovers in the area. Visit today and experience the magic of Joe's New York Style Pizza!

Wise Guys Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant in Buffalo, NY that offers a variety of service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in experiences. They are known for their comfort food offerings with highlights on fast service. Customers have shared their experiences with the restaurant, summarizing that:

• Pizza was dry and unappetizing, and the meatball sub was burnt to a crisp.
• An educated consumer enjoyed the meal and found the prices fair compared to other places.
• Customers enjoyed the large portions of the chef salad and delicious pizzas, even if not served hot.
• Despite some minor issues with the order, customers found the food to be good and enjoyable.

The overall rating of Wise Guys Pizza is 4.4 stars, making it a favorable choice for local and visiting customers seeking a delicious pizza experience.

La Nova is a renowned pizza restaurant located in Buffalo, NY. They offer a variety of service options like kerbside pickup, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers rave about their delicious BBQ wings, crispy pizzas, and friendly staff.

• Best BBQ wings with sweet, thick sauce
• History-rich place recommended by locals
• Great pizzas and perfect chicken wings
• Delicious chargrilled wings and Italian seasoned dishes

Whether you're looking for a quick bite, comfort food, or a casual dining experience, La Nova has it all! Visit their website for more information or give them a call to place your order.

Bflo Pizza Bistro is a cozy spot in Buffalo known for its delicious pizzas and fast service. Customers rave about the unique flavors and quality of the pizzas, making it a hidden gem in the city. The menu offers options for outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in experiences. The bistro is popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining, catering to a variety of preferences. Customers appreciate the fluffy crust, rich tomato sauce, and homemade croutons served at the bistro. The staff is friendly, and the atmosphere is casual and cozy, making it a perfect spot for a casual bite or a date night. With a rating of 4.9 stars and numerous positive reviews, Bflo Pizza Bistro is a must-visit for pizza lovers in Buffalo.

• Unique and delicious pizza flavors
• Quality ingredients and homemade croutons
• Fast service and friendly staff
• Cozy and casual atmosphere, perfect for a casual bite or a date night

Lovejoy Pizzeria is a beloved pizza restaurant located in Buffalo, NY. They offer a variety of service options including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers rave about their flavorful pizzas and wings, with many highlighting the bbq chicken pizza as a favorite. The pepperoni and mushroom pizza is also highly praised for its delicious taste. Lovejoy Pizzeria is known for serving quality food at great prices. The atmosphere is casual and welcoming, perfect for a meal with friends or family. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

• Phenomenal bbq chicken pizza
• Extremely delicious pepperoni and mushroom pizza
• Great cheese and pepperoni slices
• Outstanding wings with a variety of flavors

Tuscan Pizza Crust is a popular pizza restaurant located in Buffalo, NY. They offer a variety of services including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Known for their delicious comfort food and halal options, this spot is popular for lunch and dinner. Customers praise the great delivery service, friendly staff, and tasty garlic knots. The cozy casual atmosphere attracts a diverse crowd, including university students. While reservations are not accepted, the establishment does offer various payment options for convenience, such as credit cards and NFC mobile payments. Families with kids also find it to be a kid-friendly dining destination.

Customer Reviews:

• Great food!! - Takeout spot that does delivery and my go-to place to grab food. Great delivery service, along with very nice cashiers/chefs. 10/10 Halal spot for sure.
• Tried this place on a whim. Deep dish is thinner than standard buffalo pizza. It is very bland. Crust has the feel of something baked in a cookie sheet. Sausages flavorless. Very disappointing.
• This is the third time I have ordered from Tuscan. Wonderful people and delicious wraps. Always raved about the garlic knots and desserts. So yummy.
• While leaving NY back home to Cleveland, I found this establishment. The deep dish 24 slice was so delicious. Clean atmosphere, great service. Will definitely repeat when I go back.

Mineo's South Pizzeria is a beloved pizza restaurant in Buffalo, NY, known for its exceptional food and service. With a rating of 4.4 stars from 659 reviews, it's clear that customers have great things to say about this establishment.

• Consistently great food for pickup and delivery
• Phenomenal service and promptness
• Perfect spot for delicious lunch options
• Best pizza place in South Buffalo

Offering delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options, Mineo's South Pizzeria caters to a variety of preferences. The fast service highlights their commitment to providing a seamless dining experience. Whether you're a local or a tourist, this cozy and casual atmosphere is sure to make you feel right at home.

From their signature pizzas to mouthwatering wings, every item on the menu is crafted to perfection. If you're in the mood for a quick bite or looking to enjoy a meal with friends, Mineo's South Pizzeria has got you covered. Don't miss out on their delectable offerings, including comfort food and beer, making it an ideal spot for any occasion.

JJ's Casa Di Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant located in Buffalo, NY. They offer a variety of service options such as outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Known for their fast service, JJ's Casa Di Pizza is a favorite spot for both lunch and dinner.

• Customers rave about the NY style pan pizza and Buffalo Wild Wings.
• Many appreciate the kid-friendly atmosphere and awesome service.
• Some have mentioned the thick crust of the deep dish pizza and the delicious Italian sausage.

Reviews also highlight the casual and cosy atmosphere, making it a great spot for families, groups, and university students. With a rating of 4.2, JJ's Casa Di Pizza continues to delight customers with their flavorful pizzas and wings.

Lovejoy Pizzeria is a popular pizza restaurant in Buffalo, NY, known for its delicious offerings and great service. The restaurant offers various service options like delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy their favorite pizza for lunch, dinner, or even dine solo. With a rating of 4.4, it's evident that customers are happy with their experience at Lovejoy Pizzeria.

• Pizza portions are generous and delicious, perfect for solo dining.
• Customers praise the friendly and kind staff.
• Delicious wings and fresh ingredients make for a satisfying meal.

With positive reviews and a variety of payment options, Lovejoy Pizzeria is a must-visit spot for pizza lovers in Buffalo.

La Pizza Club is a beloved pizza restaurant located in Buffalo, NY, that has received rave reviews from its patrons. With a rating of 4.5 stars out of 5, customers have highlighted several key points:

• Great value for money with delicious pizza
• Exceptional customer service and kindness shown by the staff
• Authentic Italian food made the old school way
• Wide variety of menu options including unique items like Chipotle BBQ Chicken Quesodilla

Customers have expressed their satisfaction with the food quality, friendly atmosphere, and overall dining experience at La Pizza Club. Whether you're looking for a quick bite, comfort food, or a casual dining spot, this restaurant has something for everyone. Visit their website for more information and to place an order for delivery, takeaway, or dine-in.

Hearth + Press is a renowned pizza restaurant located in Buffalo, NY. Known for its delicious pizzas, fast service, and trendy atmosphere, this place offers a variety of dining options like Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. It is popular for both Lunch and Dinner, making it a perfect spot for a quick bite or a leisurely meal.

Many customers rave about their experience at Hearth + Press, highlighting the exceptional food quality, friendly staff, and vibrant ambiance. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

• This place in downtown Buffalo is a must-go with amazing food, staff, and overall vibe.
• The pizzas are phenomenal, packed with flavor and expertly crafted.
• The service is fast and friendly, adding to the enjoyable dining experience.
• Owners are incredible, creating an amazing space for great food in a relaxed atmosphere.

If you are looking for a top-notch pizza dining experience in Buffalo, make sure to visit Hearth + Press for a memorable meal!

Pizza Plant Italian Pub - Canalside is a popular brewpub in Buffalo, NY. The establishment offers a variety of services including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Customers praise the fast service and the solo dining experience, making it a great spot for those dining alone.

With a rating of 4.1, it's clear that patrons have positive experiences at Pizza Plant Italian Pub. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

• The pizza was amazing. Neat and clean environment. Great outdoor dining. Friendly and knowledgeable staff.
• Decent crowd, a lot of draft beers to choose from, good wings, and great service.
• Food and drinks could use improvement, but beer was enjoyable. Service was average.
• Confusing menu layout and slow seating process, but good food and slightly expensive drinks.

Next time you're in Buffalo, give Pizza Plant Italian Pub a try for a unique brewpub experience!

Carbone's Pizza & Subs is a popular pizza restaurant located in Buffalo, NY. They offer a variety of services including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, traditional delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. Customers love the fast service and the variety of offerings like comfort food and late-night food. The atmosphere is casual, making it a great spot for lunch, dinner, or even for solo dining. Carbone's is also known for their delicious pizza with options for different sauces like their original and award-winning sweet sauce.

• The pizza is pure Buffalo-style with a choice of traditional or sweet sauce.
• The employees are extremely friendly and the prices are reasonable compared to other places.
• Great for takeout and the seating area is clean with a couple of TVs for dine-in options.
• Supporting a local business like Carbone's is a rewarding experience.

Bailey Avenue Pizza is a popular pizza restaurant in Buffalo, NY, offering a variety of service options like delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. Known for its comfort food offerings and quick bites, this spot is a favorite for both lunch and dinner.

Customers rave about the flavorful pizzas and friendly service. Some key points from the reviews include:

• Great Buffalo Pizza with perfect crust and tons of cheese
• Occasional misses on wing quality and pizza undercooking
• Welcoming environment and excellent customer service
• Issues with food poisoning and long wait times during peak hours

With a solid 4.0 rating and over 850 reviews, Bailey Avenue Pizza continues to satisfy pizza enthusiasts in the area. Visit their website to order or stop by for a delicious meal!