Menu

New York City

The 16 Best Fish Fry in Rochester, New York

When it comes to finding the best fish fry in Rochester, New York, look no further than this comprehensive list of top-notch options. Whether you're a local looking for your usual spot or a visitor curious to try something new, this guide will help you discover the most delicious and satisfying fish fry in the area.

From classic pubs to upscale restaurants, Rochester offers a diverse range of establishments serving up tasty fish fry dishes. With so many options to choose from, you can easily find the perfect place to satisfy your cravings for this iconic dish.

Don't waste any more time searching for the best fish fry in Rochester - let this guide lead you to the perfect meal that will leave you wanting more!

The 16 Best Fish Fry in Rochester, New York:

How this guide is ordered

Chosen by our New York editors from places across the five boroughs, giving weight to a long track record with locals, current opening details and how well each one delivers on what it promises. Lists are revisited often; tell us when a spot closes or moves.

Featured businesses may pay for a more visible position within the guide.

Top 3Full listMapHow to choose

Quick view

Featured options

Select an option to see its summary.

#1
Shamrock Jack's Irish Pub
4.61,255 reviews
#2
Rabbit Hole Tavern
4.9138 reviews
#3
Winfield Grill
4.41,790 reviews

Full list

Compare 16 local options

Shamrock Jack's Irish Pub#1
What stands out

  • Customers praise the friendly service and excellent food offerings.

  • Many patrons appreciate the live music and entertainment provided.

  • The atmosphere is described as casual, cozy, and trendy, catering to a diverse crowd.

Shamrock Jack's Irish Pub

4.61,255 reviews
4554 Culver Rd, Rochester, NY 14622, United States

Shamrock Jack's Irish Pub is a lively spot for those seeking an authentic Irish pub experience. With a warm and welcoming atmosphere, this pub offers a variety of service options including outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in. Customers can enjoy great coffee and delicious desserts while participating in live music or sport.

Rabbit Hole Tavern#2
What stands out

  • Delicious food with great setting on the river

  • Exceptional service and fun atmosphere

  • Scrumptious menu offerings like rabbit stew and fried crawfish bites

  • Knowledgeable and courteous servers like Marissa and Lilly

Rabbit Hole Tavern

4.9138 reviews
284 Exchange Blvd, Rochester, NY 14608, United States

Rabbit Hole Tavern is a vibrant bar & grill located in Rochester, NY. This establishment offers a variety of services and features that cater to its customers' needs. With options like Outdoor seating, Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, and Dine-in, patrons can enjoy their meals in a way that suits them best.

The highlights of Rabbit Hole Tavern include Fast service and Live music, creating an energetic and enjoyable atmosphere for guests. Popular for both Lunch and Dinner, this tavern is an ideal spot for a quick bite or a leisurely meal.

Customers rave about their experiences at Rabbit Hole Tavern resulting in an impressive 4.9-star rating. Here are some key points from their reviews:

Winfield Grill#3
What stands out

  • The food and service never disappoint! The wings are always crispy and fresh. Customers can enjoy a welcoming atmosphere.

  • Winfield Grill is a bustling place with a variety of menu options. Customers may encounter a wait due to popularity.

  • Some customers found take-out fees to be a downside, but appreciated the exceptional soup and service. A $5.00 gift card was a nice gesture for a missed item in the order.

  • Overall, patrons have praised the bar service, holiday drink menu, and flavorful food options. However, some customers noted that seating arrangements in the bar area may be a bit restricted at times.

Winfield Grill

4.41,790 reviews
647 Winton Rd N, Rochester, NY 14609, United States

Winfield Grill is an American restaurant located in Rochester, NY. Customers can enjoy a variety of services and features such as outdoor seating, curbside pickup, takeaway, and dine-in. The establishment is known for its fast service, great cocktails, and an atmosphere perfect for sport enthusiasts.

Hose 22 Firehouse Grill#4
What stands out

  • Customers rave about the wonderful service and great atmosphere, perfect for a memorable dining experience.

  • The quality and flavor of the food, from NY strip steak to nachos with jalapeño popper dip, impress guests time and time again.

  • Visitors appreciate the historic ambiance of the converted firehouse and the quick and friendly service provided.

  • Reviewers highlight the extensive menu options, impeccable food quality, attention to detail, and varied array of beers and drinks available.

Hose 22 Firehouse Grill

4.41,530 reviews
56 Stutson St, Rochester, NY 14612, United States

Hose 22 Firehouse Grill is a beloved American restaurant located in Rochester, NY. The restaurant offers a variety of dining options, including outdoor seating, takeaway, and dine-in services. Customers can enjoy specialties such as comfort food and great cocktails in a cozy and historic atmosphere.

The Angry Goat Pub#5
What stands out

  • The food at The Angry Goat Pub is incredible, especially the Garbage Plate.

  • Customers appreciate the attentive and friendly staff, making their experience enjoyable.

  • The vibe of the pub is described as chill and inviting, perfect for socializing with friends.

  • Unique and delicious offerings like the Angry Goat Burger and duck wings are highly recommended.

The Angry Goat Pub

4.5885 reviews
938 S Clinton Ave, Rochester, NY 14620, United States

The Angry Goat Pub is a popular bar & grill located in Rochester, NY. They offer a variety of services including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The pub is known for its bar games, fast service, karaoke, live music, and sport events, making it a go-to spot for many locals and tourists.

Customer reviews rave about the incredible food at The Angry Goat Pub. One satisfied customer mentioned that the Garbage Plate is a must-try dish, highlighting the attentive and friendly staff. Another reviewer praised the unique and delicious offerings, like the Angry Goat Burger and duck wings. The overall vibe of the pub is described as chill, inviting, and perfect for hanging out with friends.

MicGinny's on the River#6
What stands out

  • Great service and atmosphere for a kickball team's sponsor

  • Easy party booking process with friendly staff

  • Fast seating, tasty food, and fantastic service

  • Good food, but some drinks were overpriced

MicGinny's on the River

4.31,385 reviews
2246 E River Rd, Rochester, NY 14623, United States

MicGinny's on the River is a popular sports bar located in Rochester, NY. The establishment offers a variety of services and features to cater to its customers' needs. Some of the service options available include outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, and takeaway. The bar also provides great beer selection, cocktails, and food options for customers to enjoy while watching sports on TV.

Customers have left reviews praising the lively atmosphere at MicGinny's and the excellent service provided by the staff. Some key points from the reviews include:

Whether you're looking to watch a game, enjoy a meal with friends, or host a party, MicGinny's on the River has something to offer for everyone.

Jeremiah's Tavern#7
What stands out

  • Good food and lots of wings flavors.

  • Great service with quick takeout options.

  • Varied menu with delicious options for both food and drinks.

Jeremiah's Tavern

4.31,228 reviews
1104 Monroe Ave, Rochester, NY 14620, United States

Jeremiah's Tavern is a popular restaurant located in Rochester, NY. The establishment offers a variety of service options, including Outdoor seating, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in to cater to different preferences. Customers can enjoy fast service, a great beer selection, and great cocktails in a comfortable atmosphere, making it an ideal spot for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. The establishment is known for its comfort food, spirits, and wine, giving patrons a wide array of options to choose from. While the venue is casual and cozy, it also attracts a diverse crowd, including family-friendly folks, groups, tourists, and university students. Customers have highlighted some key points in their reviews, such as:

The rave reviews and high rating of 4.3 showcase the quality experience and satisfaction that Jeremiah's Tavern consistently delivers to its patrons.

The Old Toad#8
What stands out

  • Great service from staff

  • Excellent beer selection and cocktails

  • Delicious British cuisine, including favorites like scotch eggs and shepherd's pie

  • Authentic pub experience with a cozy ambiance

The Old Toad

4.4700 reviews
277 Alexander St, Rochester, NY 14607, United States

The Old Toad is a charming pub located in Rochester, NY. They offer a variety of services to cater to their customers' needs, such as Takeaway and Dine-in options. The pub boasts an atmosphere that is both Casual and Trendy, making it a great spot for a night out.

Key points from customer reviews:

With a solid rating of 4.4 based on 700 reviews, customers rave about the exceptional service and quality of food at The Old Toad. Whether you're a local or a tourist, this pub is a must-visit for a taste of Britain in Rochester.

Tryon City Tavern#9
What stands out

  • Unassuming neighborhood bar with amazing occasional Mexican food and the best fish fry in town.

  • Outstanding food quality, particularly the fish fry, and excellent service with a friendly atmosphere.

  • Great place for a fish fry with kind service, but keep in mind it's more of a bar than a restaurant.

  • Unique service setup but outstanding fish fry with generous portions and fantastic taste.

Tryon City Tavern

4.5406 reviews
2300 E Main St, Rochester, NY 14609, United States

Tryon City Tavern is a neighborhood bar & grill located in Rochester, NY. They offer a variety of services including delivery, takeaway, and dine-in options. The tavern is known for its great bar food, fast service, and fun bar games. Customers have praised the craft beer tap list and wonderful bartenders.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Elmwood Inn#10
What stands out

  • The Fish and Fries were delicious, but there was a slight wait due to understaffing

  • The bartender on Tuesdays was friendly and efficient, and the food was amazing

  • Great beer selection, cozy atmosphere, and fantastic service

  • High-quality Fish Fry on Friday nights, attentive staff, and delicious food options

Elmwood Inn

4.31,033 reviews
1256 Mt Hope Ave, Rochester, NY 14620, United States

Elmwood Inn is a popular restaurant located in Rochester, NY, known for its diverse offerings and cozy atmosphere. The establishment offers a range of services, including outdoor seating, delivery, and dine-in options. Customers can enjoy a variety of amenities, such as a well-stocked bar and clean facilities.

Some key features of Elmwood Inn include fast service, a great beer selection, and delicious cocktails. The place is ideal for lunch, dinner, and solo dining experiences. Additionally, the restaurant is family-friendly and caters to tourists and groups.

Customers have praised Elmwood Inn for its welcoming atmosphere and solid food options. Reviews highlight the exceptional service provided by staff members. Here are some key points summarizing customer reviews:

Park Avenue Pub#11
What stands out

  • This is a hidden gem on Park Ave, more of a fine dining type restaurant than a pub. Highly recommended for excellent food and service.

  • Quality ingredients, made with love. Best beef stroganoff ever eaten. Friendly and accommodating staff.

  • Amazing owners, staff, atmosphere, and food. An exceptional dining experience every time.

  • Beautiful atmosphere, attentive service, but some inconsistencies in food quality and presentation.

Park Avenue Pub

4.6190 reviews
650 Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14607, United States

Park Avenue Pub is a renowned American restaurant located in Rochester, NY. The restaurant offers various services and features to cater to different preferences. Customers can enjoy outdoor seating, kerbside pickup, takeaway, and dine-in options. The establishment is known for its fast service and great dessert, making it a popular choice for lunch and dinner, as well as solo dining.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

The Old Stone Tavern#12
What stands out

  • Excellent food quality, especially the cauliflower bites and Korean bbq sauce.

  • Friendly staff and cozy vibe, perfect for a casual dining experience.

  • Wide variety on the menu, with creative and delicious options like carrot dogs and poutine made from tots.

The Old Stone Tavern

4.3726 reviews
758 South Ave, Rochester, NY 14620, United States

The Old Stone Tavern is a well-known restaurant located in Rochester, NY, offering a variety of service options such as outdoor seating, delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. This establishment is loved by customers for its fast service, great beer selection, great cocktails, live music, and sports broadcasts.

Customers have shared their positive experiences, highlighting:

With a solid rating of 4.3 and 726 reviews, The Old Stone Tavern is a popular choice for those looking for a great meal, refreshing drinks, and a fun atmosphere in Rochester.

Chick’n Out#13
What stands out

  • Great food and excellent service. Planning to visit again.

  • The chicken tenders are incredibly delicious and the honey mustard sauce is a hit.

  • The Mac n cheese and other sides could use some improvement in flavor and portion sizes.

  • The staff is friendly, and the restaurant is small but efficient for takeout orders.

Chick’n Out

4.5242 reviews
37 Charlotte St, Rochester, NY 14607, United States

Chick’n Out is a popular chicken restaurant located in Rochester, NY. They offer a variety of services such as Kerbside pickup, No-contact delivery, Delivery, Takeaway, and Dine-in. Known for being popular for Lunch and Dinner, this spot is ideal for Solo dining. Their menu features Comfort food, Late-night food, and Quick bites that keep customers coming back for more. With a rating of 4.5, Chick’n Out has garnered positive reviews from many customers.

Thurston seafood (Not Fish Market)#14
What stands out

  • Great place for fried fish, with delicious macaroni salad

  • Simple operation with a variety of seafood options

  • Excellent service with polite staff and a clean atmosphere

Thurston seafood (Not Fish Market)

4.737 reviews
425 Thurston Rd, Rochester, NY 14619, United States

Thurston Seafood (Not Fish Market) is a popular takeout restaurant located in Rochester, NY. Known for their comfort food offerings and quick bites, they offer a variety of fried fish options like catfish, tilapia, haddock, and more. Customers rave about the macaroni salad and beer battered haddock, calling it the best they've ever had.

With a rating of 4.7 stars, Thurston Seafood has impressed many customers with their crispy batter, flaky fish, and friendly staff. Whether you're craving a tasty fish fry or some crispy chicken wings, this place is sure to satisfy your cravings.

Fried Fish Shack#15
What stands out

  • I will be going back to The Fish Shack. This was worth the miles on the vehicle. Mouth watering taste with every bite. The fish is so delicious it just puts a smile on your face. I have to admit out of all fish spots I ate at this is two thumbs up. Try it to experience fresh cooked well seasoned fish.

  • Friday or not this is the place to go for fried fish! Fast and yummy you can’t go wrong! We got the haddock and shrimp combo with two sides and it was amazing, the Mac salad and coleslaw is homemade!

  • My son and I stopped here for lunch after he suggested it. What a great choice he made. Loved the food, as well as the hospitality. Very nice size portions. Food was very satisfying. Thanks for showing us love. We'll definitely be back!

  • Easily the best fried fish I've had in the area. Both the cornmeal and the battered options are great. The Shrimp was really good too. I love the house-made tartar sauce. It's sweeter than any other tartar sauce I've had, but in a good way. The house-made mac salad might be my favorite mac salad anywhere. It also has a nice sweetness to it.

Fried Fish Shack

4.4120 reviews
826 Joseph Ave, Rochester, NY 14621, United States

Fried Fish Shack is a popular fish & chips restaurant located in Rochester, NY. They offer various service options including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, takeaway, and dine-in. This cozy spot is especially popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. Customers appreciate the comfort food offerings and quick bites available. The atmosphere is described as casual, making it a great spot for families with kids.

The restaurant has received numerous positive reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some key points summarizing their experiences:

If you're a seafood fan in Rochester, Fried Fish Shack is a top spot to enjoy a variety of delicious options at an affordable price. Don't miss out on this gem where fresh, well-seasoned fish awaits you!

Hooked Fish Market#16
What stands out

  • Beware of bones in fish dinners, which led to a disappointing experience for one customer.

  • Customers appreciate the variety of fresh fish and sides, with special mentions for the dirty rice, baked beans, and Mac and cheese.

  • Many patrons commend the generous portions of food, great prices, and overall welcoming atmosphere at Hooked Fish Market.

  • Visitors from out of town are pleasantly surprised by the quality and size of the fish fillets, along with tasty sides like dirty rice and Mac and cheese.

Hooked Fish Market

4.2104 reviews
333 Driving Park Ave, Rochester, NY 14613, United States

Hooked Fish Market is a popular seafood restaurant in Rochester, NY, known for its fresh fish and hand-crafted sides. Customers rave about the delicious meals and excellent customer service provided by the owners. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.2 based on 104 reviews, this Black-owned establishment is a go-to spot for seafood lovers looking for a fulfilling and satisfying meal experience. If you're in the area, be sure to check out Hooked Fish Market for a memorable dining experience!

Summary

The comparison at a glance

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Shamrock Jack's Irish Pub 4.61,255
#2Rabbit Hole Tavern 4.9138
#3Winfield Grill 4.41,790
#4Hose 22 Firehouse Grill 4.41,530
#5The Angry Goat Pub 4.5885
#6MicGinny's on the River 4.31,385
#7Jeremiah's Tavern 4.31,228
#8The Old Toad 4.4700
#9Tryon City Tavern 4.5406
#10Elmwood Inn 4.31,033
#11Park Avenue Pub 4.6190
#12The Old Stone Tavern 4.3726
#13Chick’n Out 4.5242
#14Thurston seafood (Not Fish Market) 4.737
#15Fried Fish Shack 4.4120
#16Hooked Fish Market 4.2104

For businesses

Run a business?

Manage or add my business

Map and areas

Map of Fish Fry in Rochester, New York

Rochester, New York is known for its vibrant fish fry culture, with countless restaurants offering their own unique take on the classic dish. Whether you prefer it beer-battered, pan-seared, or breaded, there's a fish fry spot in town to satisfy your cravings. Explore the map below to discover all the top spots to indulge in this beloved Rochester tradition.

How to choose Fish Fry in New York City

  1. Locations across Rochester.
  2. Classic pub-style fish fries.
  3. Upscale restaurants with gourmet options.
  4. Traditional and innovative recipes.
  5. Outdoor dining available.

Frequently asked questions

What is a fish fry?

A fish fry typically consists of battered and deep-fried fish, often served with a side of fries and coleslaw. It is a popular dish in the Rochester, New York area, especially during Lenten season. Restaurants and community organizations in Rochester often host fish fry events on Fridays, catering to those looking for a delicious and traditional meal. Some establishments offer variations of the classic fish fry, including baked or grilled fish options for those looking for a healthier alternative.

Where can I find the best fish fry in Rochester?

When looking for the best fish fry in Rochester, it's important to consider factors such as freshness of the fish, quality of the batter, and overall taste of the dish. Local restaurants known for their standout fish fry dishes include Charley Brown's Restaurant, Jeremiah's Tavern, and WINTONAIRE. Community events, such as fish fry fundraisers at churches and schools, are also great opportunities to sample delicious fish fry in Rochester.

What sides are typically served with a fish fry?

Traditional sides that are often served with a fish fry include French fries, coleslaw, tartar sauce, and lemon wedges. Some restaurants in Rochester offer additional side options such as macaroni salad, baked beans, or hush puppies to complement the fish fry. For those looking for a lighter option, a side of steamed vegetables or a garden salad can also be a refreshing accompaniment to a fish fry meal.

Are there any fish fry specials in Rochester?

Many restaurants in Rochester offer specials on fish fry dishes, especially on Fridays when it is a popular menu item. Some establishments may have discounted prices on their fish fry meals during happy hour or early bird specials. Keep an eye out for promotions and offers on social media or restaurant websites to take advantage of great deals on delicious fish fry in Rochester.

Related guides

The 16 Best Tomahawk Steaks in New YorkThe 16 Best Bialy New YorkThe 16 Best Vegan Restaurants in New York