Menu

The 16 Best New York Crumb Cake

When it comes to indulging in a sweet treat, few things beat sinking your teeth into a moist and buttery slice of New York crumb cake. With its generous layer of crumb topping made of butter, sugar, and cinnamon, this classic dessert is a beloved staple in bakeries across the city.

Whether you're a local craving a taste of nostalgia or a visitor looking to experience a quintessential New York treat, finding the perfect slice of crumb cake can be a delicious adventure. To help you on your quest, we've compiled a list of the best places to satisfy your craving for this beloved dessert.

Get ready to sink your teeth into the best New York crumb cake around with our carefully curated list below.

How we chose and ordered them

The order here is based on merit: a business that focuses on this work and has a solid reputation ranks above one that only offers it on the side.

No business can pay to be included. Those already in the guide may buy extra visibility, and it is always shown.

Top 3All optionsMapWhat to look for

Weigh 16 local options side by side

Crumbl - Upper East Side, New York City#1
What it does well
  • A nice sweet treat with new flavors every week

  • Fast self-serve ordering process

  • Huge cookies that are soft and not overwhelmingly sweet

  • Delicious cookies that stay fresh for days

Crumbl - Upper East Side

4.82,181 reviews
1195 3rd Ave, New York, NY 10021, United States

Crumbl - Upper East Side is a beloved dessert shop in New York, offering a variety of delectable cookies that keep customers coming back for more. With a stellar rating of 4.8, it's no wonder that this place is a favorite among locals and visitors alike.

Customers rave about the service options provided by Crumbl - Upper East Side, including kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, delivery, in-store pick-up, and more. Additionally, the free parking lot makes it convenient for customers to grab their sweet treats. So if you're in the mood for some scrumptious cookies, make sure to visit Crumbl - Upper East Side soon!

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery, New York City#2
What it does well
  • The staff is welcoming and friendly.

  • The cakes are stunning and taste incredible.

  • The display of treats never disappoints.

  • Customers highly recommend the Oreo balls and all other delicious treats at Crumbly.

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery

4.9159 reviews
997 1st Ave., New York, NY 10022, United States

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery is a beloved bakery located in New York, offering a wide range of delicious treats. Customers rave about the welcoming and friendly staff, as well as the stunning and incredible cakes available at the bakery. Here are some key points from customer reviews:

With a rating of 4.9 stars and glowing reviews, Crumbly Cafe & Bakery is a must-visit for anyone with a sweet tooth in New York City.

Levain Bakery, New York City#3
What it does well
  • Best cookies ever!

  • Love the atmosphere and decor

  • Staff were super nice and friendly

  • Cookies are perfectly baked, crunchy on the outside and soft on the inside

Levain Bakery

4.72,421 reviews
340 Lafayette St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Levain Bakery is a renowned bakery located in the heart of New York City. Offering a variety of services including delivery, in-store pick-up, in-store shopping, takeaway, and dine-in, this bakery caters to a wide range of customers. Customers with accessibility needs will also appreciate the wheelchair-accessible entrance at this location.

One of the highlights of Levain Bakery is its mouth-watering selection of cookies, including the Dark Chocolate Peanut Butter Cookie and the Chocolate Chip Walnut Cookie. Customers rave about the exceptional service they receive at this bakery, with staff described as super nice and friendly with big smiles.

Here are some key points from customer reviews:

Visit Levain Bakery for an unforgettable bakery experience!

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery, New York City#4
What it does well
  • Customers rave about the vast variety of bakery items and drinks available.

  • The friendly and welcoming staff receive high praise from visitors.

  • The quality of the desserts like double chocolate cake, blueberry cake, and cannolis is exceptional.

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery

4.978 reviews
1729 2nd Ave, New York, NY 10128, United States

Crumbly Cafe & Bakery is a beloved establishment in New York known for its delectable treats and cozy atmosphere. With a rating of 4.9 based on 78 reviews, it's clear that customers absolutely adore this bakery.

Whether you're in the mood for a scrumptious red velvet cupcake or a flavorful pumpkin cheesecake, Crumbly Cafe & Bakery has everything you need to satisfy your sweet tooth. Stop by today and treat yourself to a delightful experience!

NY Bakery and Desserts, New York City#5
What it does well
  • Customers appreciate the extensive selection of desserts and the quality of the treats.

  • The staff is friendly, helpful, and provides excellent service.

  • Many visitors praise the delicious coffee and complimentary treats offered at the bakery.

  • The bakery's location in Times Square is convenient for both locals and tourists alike.

NY Bakery and Desserts

4.7544 reviews

Open 24 hours

1580 Broadway, New York, NY 10036, United States

NY Bakery and Desserts offers a wide range of delicious treats and sweets in the heart of New York City. With services like No-contact delivery, In-store shopping, and Dine-in, customers can enjoy their favorite desserts in the way that suits them best. The bakery is known for its friendly staff and welcoming atmosphere, making every visit a delightful experience.

NY Bakery and Desserts, New York City#7
What it does well
  • Customers appreciate the friendly and helpful staff who provide great service without expecting tips.

  • The bakery offers a wide selection of vibrant and fresh products, including amazing desserts and coffee.

  • The desserts are delicious, with standout items like the Ferrero Rocher mousse and the strawberry cake receiving high praise.

  • Overall, customers highly recommend NY Bakery and Desserts for its tasty treats and excellent service.

NY Bakery and Desserts

4.61,980 reviews

Open 24 hours

512 7th Ave, New York, NY 10018, United States

NY Bakery and Desserts is a charming bakery located in the heart of New York. They offer a variety of delicious pastries, cakes, and desserts that will delight any sweet tooth. Customers can enjoy no-contact delivery or choose to pick up in-store. The bakery also offers in-store shopping, takeaway, and the option to dine-in and enjoy their treats right on the spot. The service is exceptional, with friendly staff ready to assist customers in choosing the perfect snack.

Here are some key points summarizing customer reviews:

The Better Crumb, New York City#8
What it does well
  • The Piped Flower cupcakes were a hit at a baby shower, they not only looked amazing but tasted fantastic too!

  • Quick and efficient service with delicious chocolate chip cookies delivered right on time!

  • Beautiful custom birthday cookies made with luxurious royal icing, great pricing, and excellent communication.

  • High-quality ingredients shine in these cookies, which are rich, substantial, and incredibly good!

The Better Crumb

5.024 reviews
360 1st Ave., New York, NY 10010, United States

The Better Crumb is a delightful cookie shop located in New York, NY. They offer kerbside pickup and delivery services, making it convenient for customers to enjoy their delicious treats. The bakery requires an appointment for visits and accepts credit cards for payment.

Customers have raved about their experiences at The Better Crumb with a perfect 5.0 rating. Here are some key points from the reviews:

Customers have praised the bakery for its personal touch and professional experience, with one reviewer noting that it feels like a hidden gem in the city. Whether you're in the mood for classic chocolate chip cookies or decadent cupcakes, The Better Crumb is sure to satisfy your sweet cravings.

Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC, New York City#9
What it does well
  • One customer found the donuts to be dense but believes others should give it a try.

  • Another patron expressed disappointment due to the closure of the bakery but looks forward to revisiting it.

  • A satisfied customer praised the delicious cakes, friendly staff, and recommended the bakery to others.

  • One enthusiastic visitor was pleasantly surprised by the flavorful cupcakes and donuts, rating the experience 100/10.

Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC

4.3744 reviews
248 Broome St, New York, NY 10002, United States

Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC is a beloved bakery located in New York, offering a range of delectable vegan and gluten-free treats. With options for Delivery, In-store pick-up, In-store shopping, and Takeaway, this bakery caters to a variety of preferences. The bakery is known for its quick service and accepts various payment methods such as credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments.

Customer reviews highlight some key points:

Overall, Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC has garnered a positive reputation among customers who value vegan and gluten-free baked goods. Visit the bakery to indulge in flavorful treats and experience exceptional customer service.

Crumbl - Upper West Side, New York City#10
What it does well
  • Varied and delicious weekly flavor selections

  • Impeccably clean environment and friendly staff

  • Unique cookie factory experience within the store

Crumbl - Upper West Side

4.81,056 reviews
301 Columbus Ave, New York, NY 10023, United States

Crumbl - Upper West Side is a renowned dessert shop located in New York, offering a range of delectable sweets for every palate. Customers can enjoy services such as kerbside pickup, delivery, in-store pick-up, takeaway, and same-day delivery. The establishment also provides quick visit options and accepts credit cards for payment. Conveniently, there is free parking available, making it hassle-free for customers to indulge in their favorite treats.

With a stellar rating of 4.8 stars based on 1056 reviews, Crumbl - Upper West Side has garnered attention for its exceptional quality and flavors. Customers praise the shop for various reasons, summarized as follows:

Visitors have particularly raved about the strawberry pretzel cookie, Kentucky butter cake, and sugar ft mother’s circus animal among the irresistible offerings. Don't miss the opportunity to treat yourself to an unforgettable dessert experience at Crumbl - Upper West Side!

Crumbl - West Village, New York City#11
What it does well
  • The cookies are delicious and fresh, with changing menu options

  • A wide selection of cookies and baked goods to choose from

  • Quick service with a lovely packaging experience

Crumbl - West Village

4.8568 reviews
195 Bleecker St, New York, NY 10012, United States

Crumbl - West Village is a popular dessert shop located at 195 Bleecker St, New York, NY. The business offers a variety of services, including kerbside pickup, delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway. Customers can enjoy the convenience of credit card payments and benefit from free parking while visiting the store.

With a high rating of 4.8 stars out of 5 based on 568 reviews, Crumbl - West Village has garnered a strong reputation. Customers have shared positive feedback, highlighting the following key points:

Some customers have also provided constructive feedback, suggesting improvements in packaging and service quality. Despite these minor concerns, the overall consensus is positive, making Crumbl - West Village a favorite destination for dessert lovers in New York City.

CMNY Cakes, New York City#12
What it does well
  • Beautiful and tasty cake for a first birthday party.

  • Impressive, flawless, creative cakes for special events.

  • Extremely detailed and delicious custom cakes, although appointments may be challenging to secure.

  • Fabulous, delicious cakes that meet specific dietary needs and are delivered with exceptional service.

CMNY Cakes

4.216 reviews
192 Lexington Ave, New York, NY 10016, United States

CMNY Cakes is a renowned cake shop located in New York, offering a wide range of services to meet all your cake needs. Some key features of this business include identifying as Asian-owned and providing no-contact delivery, delivery, and takeaway options for your convenience. Customers rave about the exceptional service and quality of cakes they receive from CMNY Cakes. Here are some summarized reviews:

New York Cake Pops, New York City#13
What it does well
  • Personalized and timely delivery service for special occasions.

  • High-quality and cute designs that exceed expectations.

  • Efficient communication and prompt responses for orders.

  • Attention to detail and going above and beyond for customer satisfaction.

New York Cake Pops

4.715 reviews
nan

New York Cake Pops is a top-rated Bakery that offers exceptional services to its customers. The business provides Delivery options, making it convenient for clients to enjoy their delicious treats. Customers have left glowing reviews about their experiences at New York Cake Pops. Some key points from their reviews include:

If you're looking for beautifully crafted cake pops that taste as good as they look, New York Cake Pops is the perfect choice.

Crumbl - Chelsea, New York City#14
What it does well
  • The semi-sweet chocolate chip cookie is a favorite for its taste, but some caution about the high sugar content and calorie count.

  • First-time visitors love the freshness and deliciousness of the cookies, recommending the spot to others.

  • There have been instances of delivery issues with broken cookies, leading to a disappointment in service quality.

  • Customers appreciate the friendly service despite some minor hiccups, like a cold cashier, and express gratitude for an outstanding employee named Lisa who went above and beyond to ensure a positive experience.

Crumbl - Chelsea

4.7503 reviews
238 7th Ave, New York, NY 10011, United States

Crumbl - Chelsea is a popular dessert shop located in New York, offering a variety of delectable cookies that keep customers coming back for more. They provide various service options such as kerbside pickup, no-contact delivery, in-store pick-up, and more, making it convenient for customers to enjoy their treats. One of the key highlights of Crumbl - Chelsea is their freshly made cookies that receive rave reviews from satisfied customers. Here are some summarized customer reviews:

If you're in the mood for scrumptious cookies with a hint of excitement in flavors, Crumbl - Chelsea is the place to indulge your sweet tooth in the heart of the city.

The Original Cake Man Raven, New York City#15
What it does well
  • Spectacular cakes loved by families for special occasions

  • Challenges with communication and professionalism

  • Moist and delicious Red Velvet cake highly recommended

  • Great variety of cakes to choose from

The Original Cake Man Raven

3.9130 reviews
201 W 135th St, New York, NY 10030, United States

The Original Cake Man Raven is a renowned cake shop in the heart of New York City. They offer a variety of Service options including delivery, in-store pick-up, and takeaway. Customers can enjoy their delicious cakes through quick visits, making it convenient for those on the go. The business accepts various payment methods such as credit cards, debit cards, and NFC mobile payments for added convenience.

With a Rating of 3.9, The Original Cake Man Raven has earned the trust of many customers. Based on reviews, here are the key points summarized:

A summary of the options

#BusinessRatingReviews
#1Crumbl - Upper East Side 4.82,181
#2Crumbly Cafe & Bakery 4.9159
#3Levain Bakery 4.72,421
#4Crumbly Cafe & Bakery 4.978
#5NY Bakery and Desserts 4.7544
#6Cookie Crumz 4.884
#7NY Bakery and Desserts 4.61,980
#8The Better Crumb 5.024
#9Erin McKenna's Bakery NYC 4.3744
#10Crumbl - Upper West Side 4.81,056
#11Crumbl - West Village 4.8568
#12CMNY Cakes 4.216
#13New York Cake Pops 4.715
#14Crumbl - Chelsea 4.7503
#15The Original Cake Man Raven 3.9130
#16Crumb Cookie 3.589

Own a local business?

Add or claim my business

Map of New York Crumb Cake

Indulge in the iconic New York crumb cake with our comprehensive map of the best bakeries and cafes serving up this delicious treat. Whether you're a native New Yorker or just visiting the city, you won't want to miss out on these mouthwatering crumb cakes that are sure to satisfy your sweet tooth. Check out our map below to discover where you can find the best New York crumb cake in town.

How to pick crumb cake in New York City

  1. Local bakeries with a classic recipe.
  2. Cafes and coffee shops serving up fresh crumb cake daily.
  3. Specialty bakeries offering unique twists on the traditional dessert.
  4. Online bakeries that ship nationwide for those craving a taste of New York.

Common questions

What makes New York crumb cake so popular?

New York crumb cake is beloved for its generous topping of buttery, crumbly streusel. The tender cake base complements the sweet, crunchy crumb layer perfectly. This winning combination of flavors and textures is what sets New York crumb cake apart from other types of coffee cakes. Additionally, the size of traditional New York crumb cake slices tends to be larger than average, offering a satisfying treat for dessert or breakfast. The nostalgic appeal of this classic treat adds to its popularity, evoking memories of enjoying a slice at a cozy bakery or diner in New York City. Whether enjoyed with a cup of coffee as a morning indulgence or served as a dessert with a scoop of vanilla ice cream, New York crumb cake remains a timeless favorite among cake lovers.

How is New York crumb cake different from other types of coffee cake?

New York crumb cake stands out from other varieties of coffee cake due to its emphasis on the crumb topping. While traditional coffee cakes may feature a light dusting of streusel or a simple glaze, New York crumb cake boasts a thick layer of buttery crumbs that nearly equals the amount of cake beneath it. This substantial crumb topping is a defining feature of New York crumb cake, adding a rich, decadent element to the dessert. The contrast between the soft, moist cake and the crisp, crumbly topping creates a delightful texture that is unmatched by other coffee cakes. While other coffee cakes may focus on a balance of flavors and a subtle sweetness, New York crumb cake boldly embraces its crumb topping as the star of the show, making it a decadent and indulgent treat for those with a sweet tooth.

Can I make New York crumb cake at home?

Yes, it is possible to recreate the irresistible flavors of New York crumb cake in your own kitchen. With a few simple ingredients and a bit of baking know-how, you can whip up a delicious homemade version of this classic treat. Start by preparing a moist cake batter using a combination of flour, sugar, butter, eggs, and other essential ingredients. While the cake bakes, mix together a crumb topping featuring flour, sugar, cinnamon, and cold butter to achieve that signature streusel crunch. Once the cake is baked, generously pile the crumb topping on top and return it to the oven to bake until golden brown and fragrant. Allow the cake to cool before slicing and serving for a homemade taste of New York crumb cake in your own home.

How should New York crumb cake be stored to maintain freshness?

To keep New York crumb cake fresh and flavorful, it is essential to store it properly once it has been baked or purchased. Crumb cake should be stored in an airtight container or wrapped tightly in plastic wrap to prevent it from drying out. If you have purchased a large crumb cake that you cannot finish in one sitting, consider slicing it into individual portions before storing them to maintain freshness. The slices can be stored in an airtight container in the fridge for up to a week or frozen for longer-term storage. When ready to enjoy, simply remove a slice from the fridge or freezer and allow it to come to room temperature. To enhance the flavor and texture of the cake, you can warm it in the oven for a few minutes before serving. This method will help preserve the deliciousness of New York crumb cake for as long as possible.

Similar guides